Andrew RushJun 08, 2012

Making Pictures based on NASA Imagery

My favorite NASA image is AS8-14-2383, taken by William Anders on Christmas Eve, 1968. More commonly known as Earthrise, this photograph was taken the very first time humans orbited the Moon! The image of the Earth as a pale blue dot rising over the desolate surface of the Moon has been credited with birthing the environmental movement. Earthrise is a public domain image, free for use by anyone because the photograph was taken by a US astronaut on a NASA mission. Under the copyright law of the time, the federal government could not claim copyright in photos, writings, movies, and other creative works it made. The same holds true in modern copyright law. 17 USC §105 denies copyright protection for works produced by the federal government.

Earthrise over the lunar horizon from Apollo 8
Earthrise over the lunar horizon from Apollo 8 Earth rose over the lunar horizon as Apollo 8 completed the first manned trip behind the far side of the Moon. The mission also returned the first live television coverage of the lunar surface, on December 24, 1968.Image: NASA

Earthrise has been copied, revised, adapted for other media, integrated into other pictures, and modified countless times by a multitude of people. Similarly, other NASA images, like the beautiful pictures captured by the Hubble Space Telescope, are often wildly popular in their original forms as well as inspiration for modified creative endeavors. Despite using an image not granted copyright protections, makers of pieces based in whole or in part on government creations may have limited copyright protection because they have produced “derivative” or “compilation” works.

What is a derivative work?

A derivative work is a work based on one or more already existing works. A work is anything which is copyrightable. Photos, writings, music, motion pictures, sound recordings, architectural creations, and even pantomimes are all copyrightable. Simply basing your “new” work on someone else’s might not be enough for copyright protection to arise in your derivative work. Two important criteria must be satisfied in order to gain copyright protection. First, the new work must possess some creative difference which makes it readily distinguishable from the original work.

Derivative Work?


Derivative Work?
An original version of the famous Hubble Deep Field photo (top) and an altered version of the same photo (bottom). Removing two galaxies from the upper left of the Hubble Deep Field photograph is permitted because this image is public domain, but is unlikely to result in a copyright in the altered image.

For example, take a look at the two Hubble Deep Field images here. The image on the top is an original NASA image, in the public domain. The other is a candidate image for copyright protection as a derivative image because I have altered it. Look closely, can you see the alteration? Because my creative endeavor did not yield up an image possessing creative differences which are readily apparent compared to the original NASA image on the top (or was it the bottom?), I failed a criterion for copyright protection of my derivative image and don’t have a copyright in my image on the bottom (or was it the top?).

Secondly, if the original image is copyrighted, you must have permission from the copyright holder to create a derivative work. In the case of NASA starscapes, government creations, and works published before 1923, permission is not required because these works are in the public domain! If the work is copyrighted and you don’t secure permission to make a derivative work from the copyright holder, your new creation is not eligible for copyright protection! Creating derivative works is one of the exclusive rights granted to the copyright holder. In the case of derivative works, the government will not give an individual a copyright where they have violated someone else’s rights. This is an important hurdle to keep in mind when creating something based on a space image because some images of space or pictures of spacecraft come from private sources. For example, this image of SpaceX’s dragon spacecraft floating in the pacific was taken by a private citizen, not government organization, therefore one would have to ask permission to make a derivative work of it! Similarly, these images of the edge of space snapped by Armadillo Aerospace’s STIG-A rocket are owned by Armadillo Aerospace, as a private company.

Remember, a work based on anther work must be creatively distinguishable from the original work and you have to have permission to use the original work from its copyright holder (where applicable) in order to have a copyright in your new creation!

What about mosaic of space pictures??

This “self-portrait” of NASA’s Mars Exploration Rover Opportunity is a compilation of several individual images. All the images, as well as the mosaic itself, are public domain because they were produced by NASA.

Opportunity Deck Pan, December 2011 (sols 2811-2814)
Opportunity Deck Pan, December 2011 (sols 2811-2814) Opportunity used its Pancam to take the images combined into this mosaic view of the rover. The downward-looking view omits the mast on which the camera is mounted. Heading into its fifth Martian winter, Opportunity's solar panels were dustier than ever, requiring the team to choose an area of high northward tilt to increase power.Image: NASA / JPL-Caltech / Cornell

Some people like to make collages of things. One area of collaging is space imagery and there are some really awesome ones, like this one and these colliding galaxies. Is it kosher to do this? Are these collages copyrightable? In some circumstances, the answer to both questions is “yes!” Remember, notwithstanding fair use and other exceptions, reproducing another person’s copyrighted work without their permission is infringing behavior! Copying another’s pictures and inserting them into a compilation is still infringing. The copyright office will not grant copyright protection for portions of a collage or other compilation that contains copyrighted images. Copyright is applicable to the non-infringing portions of the collage or other compilation, therefore a collage of NASA images of the Space Shuttle and privately taken pictures of V2 rockets will be copyrightable only with respect to the public domain NASA images and private images where permission to use has been granted.

A final note

Derivative works, collages, and compilations based on or containing public domain works do not reapply copyright protections and limitations to the public domain works! An individual or corporation cannot remove an image or a story or a musical composition from the public domain and limit the general public’s ability to use that work by repackaging it in some creative new way. Recasting a classic fairy tale in modern New York or integrating a NASA image of the Earth from space into a cover of a magazine does not prevent private individuals from utilizing the underlying creative work for their own purposes.

Happy creating!

Let’s Go Beyond The Horizon

Every success in space exploration is the result of the community of space enthusiasts, like you, who believe it is important. You can help usher in the next great era of space exploration with your gift today.

Donate Today