Help Shape the Future of Space Exploration

Join The Planetary Society Now Join Now!

Join our eNewsletter for updates & action alerts

   Please leave this field empty

Headshot of Emily Lakdawalla

Figuring out the shape of Mars (and other places)

Posted by Emily Lakdawalla

19-01-2010 13:31 CST

Topics: pretty pictures, explaining image processing, amateur image processing, Mars, Enceladus, Mars Reconnaissance Orbiter, Cassini

I've been following a fascinating thread over on, where an amateur named Bernhard Braun ("nirgal" on unmannedspaceflight) has been posting the results from a new piece of software he's developed that generates 3-D models of landscapes from single photos. Here's just one of many stunning examples from that discussion thread:

Martian landscape from photoclinometry

Image data: NASA / JPL / UA; 3D model: Bernhard Braun

Martian landscape from photoclinometry
This 3D view of Mars was calculated using a single HiRISE image of a Martian gully. The 3D view is vertically exaggerated by a factor of 2 or 3.

To give some background on what he's doing, determining the shape or topography of a landscape is very important for understanding its geologic history. Here on Earth, we've traditionally gotten topography through meticulous surveys performed by surveyors with theodolites, walking from place to place to determine the location and elevation of specific points. Most recently, satellites have replaced human surveyors for the widest surveys; last year came the latest and greatest of global maps of Earth's topography from the Advanced Spaceborne Thermal Emission and Reflection Radiometer (ASTER) instrument on the Terra satellite. But you'll still see human surveyors out doing their work to develop very local-scale topographic maps before starting work on any construction project.

Few space missions have had dedicated instruments designed to measure the topography of distant worlds. Laser altimeters are relatively recent arrivals to spacecraft payloads: they have gone to space on Mars Global Surveyor, Hayabusa, Kaguya, Chang'E 1, Lunar Reconnaissance Orbiter, and MESSENGER to create global topographic maps of Mars, Itokawa, the Moon, and Mercury. Before these, Magellan mapped Venus' global topography with a radar altimeter. Cassini uses its radio instrument in an altimetric mode on Titan, but will only get scattered profiles, nothing like a global map.

What to do without measurements of a place's topography? Space scientists have gotten very tricky with processing image data to produce topographic maps. The best way to do this is to use parallax: take two images of the same area at slightly different angles, match features between them, and measure how they shift to produce a digital elevation model. This is the same way human stereo vision works. Stereoclinometry, as it's called, is computationally intensive, but recent missions have actually carried camera instruments that are specifically designed to take sets of images for stereoclinometry. The High Resolution Stereo Camera on Mars Express takes multiple sets of images as it orbits Mars, some looking ahead of Mars Express' orbit, some behind, and these different-angle images are combined on the ground to produce digital elevation models. The Mars Exploration Rovers actually perform autonomous generation of 3D models of their landscapes as seen through their engineering cameras as they drive, to help them determine where there are hazards in their environments. Even if you only have one camera, you can merge two views taken from different angles to produce topographic maps; that's how Paul Schenk created his 3D views of the Galilean moons.

But, a lot of the time, you don't have two images of the same area; you only have one. What to do in this situation? You use photoclinometry, also known as shape-from-shading. Imagine a crumpled piece of paper lit by a spotlight. Facets of the crumpled paper that are perpendicular to the spotlight will appear brightest; facets tilted away from the spotlight will appear dark. If you assume that everything in the picture reflects light in the same way, then you can tell by its albedo, or brightness, whether it is tilted toward or away from the light source.

Obviously this doesn't work so well if there's a lot of color variation across a surface. But the assumption of constant reflectance properties actually doesn't work too badly for most space surfaces. On Mars, this is one situation in which the globally distributed dust helps scientists, disguising the colors of the landscape, helping to emphasize topographic variations.

Here's another of Braun's images, this one of a bit of Enceladus.

3D view of an Enceladan landscape

Image data: NASA / JPL / SSI; 3D model: Bernhard Braun

3D view of an Enceladan landscape
This 3D view of Enceladus is based upon a topographic model calculated using photoclinometry on a single Cassini image of the moon.

Here's the image he made it from. The 3D view is looking along the complex of fissures on the left-hand side of the original image. I checked the latest map of Enceladus from the USGS and it's not clear to me if that set of fractures has a name yet. One fracture arcing off to the left of the image is Khorasan Fossa, but I can't tell if that set is part of Khorasan or not. The craters at the right of the image have wonderful names like Behram, Shakashik, and Zumurrud.




In the discussion in that thread, it seems that Braun's software is doing an unusually good job of capturing fine-scale variations in local topography within the images, but has more trouble with topography on longer scales. Combining his work with the more regionally accurate 3D models made from stereoclinometry could make these 3D views even better.

See other posts from January 2010


Or read more blog entries about: pretty pictures, explaining image processing, amateur image processing, Mars, Enceladus, Mars Reconnaissance Orbiter, Cassini


Leave a Comment:

You must be logged in to submit a comment. Log in now.
Facebook Twitter Email RSS AddThis

Blog Search

LightSail - Flight by Light

Support LightSail!

In 2016, The Planetary Society’s LightSail program will take the technology a step further.

I want to help!

Featured Images

Surveyor 7 panorama

Earth, as seen by Surveyor 7
Cratered caprock within Elorza crater, Mars
Point Lake, Curiosity sol 302
More Images

Featured Video

View Larger »

Space in Images

Pretty pictures and
awe-inspiring science.

See More

Join the New Millennium Committee

Let’s invent the future together!

Become a Member

Connect With Us

Facebook! Twitter! Google+ and more…
Continue the conversation with our online community!