Help Shape the Future of Space Exploration

Join The Planetary Society Now  arrow.png

Join our eNewsletter for updates & action alerts

    Please leave this field empty
Blogs

Casey Profile Picture Thumbnail

Cosmos with Cosmos Episode 3: The Harmony of the Worlds

In which Mars changes the course of human history

Posted by Casey Dreier

29-10-2013 3:33 CDT

Topics: product review, history, fun


Cosmos with Cosmos is a weekly series that encourages people to get together and watch Cosmos with a cosmo(politan) or drink of your choice. We're posting weekly episode recaps and discussion through February of 2014. This series is made possible by members of the Planetary Society. If you like what you're reading, please consider joining the Society or donating $10 to help support projects like this in the future. To learn more about this series and find out how to watch Cosmos, see our introduction.


« Episode 2: One Voice in
the Cosmic Fugue
Episode 4: Heaven & Hell »

I'm often asked to justify the study of the solar system given the larger problems of the world. There can be a strange hostility to spending money and time on this seemingly-esoteric field or for sending a robotic probe to a planetary body. And there are some people who just shrug and say "so what?" when talking about astronomy.

This is a major, major problem, and not just in astronomy and planetary science. If the majority of the public doesn't feel a benefit - or even a connection - to science, then we risk losing the institutional support that sustains this profound advance of human knowledge in which we are so fortunate to live.

Cosmos, as a series, is a rebuke to the "so whats" of the world. It celebrates the connections between individuals and the universe, between technological advances and the sparks behind them, and how astronomy served as the prime mover of the modern world.

Sagan states this rather baldly midway through the episode as he explains the apparent motion of planets across the night sky (emphasis mine): "The real solution is that the planets are worlds, that the Earth is one of them, and that they all go around the sun according to precise mathematical laws. This discovery has led directly to our modern, global civilization."

Episode 3, "The Harmony of the Worlds," demonstrates just how this occurred, though it addresses it somewhat more obliquely than I'd prefer. The physical manifestation of this moment serves as the heart and soul of this episode: Johannes Kepler, a courageous, contradictory, brilliant man living in a time of squalor and strife.

But the episode begins with a focus on astrology, a memetic virus that has infected human thought for thousands of years.

Sagan joyously demolishes the pseudo-science of astrology, and not just with strong, logical arguments, but by highlighting the provincial small-mindedness of the subject. The sequence contrasting the magnificent strangeness of the planets with their astrological doppelgängers is beautifully done. The "regal" nature of astrology's Jupiter is small potatoes compared to the whipping winds of its great red spot, three times the size of Earth. Why choose astrology when the astronomical reality is far more grand?

Astrology is, in some ways, wonderfully human. It epitomizes our deep contradictions and insecurities: the need to feel important and also powerless to fate; the desire to know our future so we may alter it; to explain away our faults but to take credit for our ability. It is the inverse of modern astronomy. In astrology we are the main characters; in astronomy, insignificant bystanders in the great cosmic destiny.

We leave astrology behind and cut to Sagan in the desert, building a campfire (a nice symbolic moment), where he introduces us to the idea of predictability behind certain physical behaviors in the world. This idea of predictability, as I discussed in the Episode 1 writeup, is the fundamental conceit of science - it's why we have a cosmos (order) instead of a chaos.

As Sagan directs us to the night sky, we see the familiar constellation of the Big Dipper among the stars. But then a new pattern of lines laid over the new stars creates something unfamiliar. The subsequent patterns even more so. Displaying the alternate constellations over the same set of "big dipper" stars is another subtle attack on astrology as well as an important reminder at our own cultural chauvinism.

The constellations tend to be taught to us at a young age. For many people, their education in astronomy ends there. It's what they take with them into adulthood. Constellations are what people always ask about at star parties or during dark nights over the glowing embers of a fire. People internalize ideas taught to them as children and, as Sagan implies, these human-made patterns may be conflated with the actual science of astronomy. But they are arbitrary projections of human culture onto the sky above us. There's no reason they have the patterns they do, beyond that we share some cultural history with the first peoples to apply that interpretation of them. Tragically, what most people know about the night sky is the least important - and least scientific - quality.

Ancient Egyptian Usra Major Constellation

Cosmos

Ancient Egyptian Usra Major Constellation
One of the more creative interpretations of the same set of stars as the "big dipper."

Astrology, so concerned about which constellation is rising when and what star is in what constellation, loses all basis in reality upon the realization that other cultures have completely different ideas about what those constellations are. This is it's fundamental flaw: subjectivity.

Astronomy, as we see in this episode, is the opposite. It depends on the objective reality of the night sky. The idea that any thinking person will eventually reach the same conclusions regarding properties of the stars as any other - regardless of their culture. There is no Egyptian astronomy (or European, or Indian, or alien, etc). Few moments are more important to the history of science than the separation of subjective and objective interpretations of the night sky.

Kepler straddled this divide, this watershed. He had deep respect for data but never truly abandoned his theory of the geometrical relationship between the orbits of the planets. He embraced numerology and astrology, working for large portions of his life as a court astrologer, but simultaneously used mathematics to represent natural behavior. His work would ultimately destroy the respectability of his astrological career.

But there's a delightful irony in this. Though astrology traffics in the arrogant falsehood of the stars' influence on our lives, the motion of the planets have exerted a powerful influence on the course of human affairs.

Planetary motion occupies an accessible, inbetween state of natural movement. Unlike falling objects here on Earth, for example, they are slow and their positions are relatively easy to measure with primitive instruments. They move in a vacuum, so their velocity is simple - no need to worry about drag, shear, or other fluid dynamics to disrupt motion. But their movements are just complex enough to defy simple explanation. Think if Earth had been the outermost planet - would we have progressed beyond the Ptolemaic concept of an Earth-centered universe and circular orbits? The planets are the perfect compromise between complexity and the possibility of measurement. Their strange retrograde motion and elliptical orbits - particularly that of Mars - compelled Kepler to ponder and eventually overturn long-held beliefs about how they moved.

Like Mars, Kepler was eccentric. It was only because of his then-unheard of commitment to the accuracy of his theoretical predictions that drove him to demote the planetary orbits from perfect circles to ellipses; to state that planetary velocity was not constant, but sped up and slowed down depending on their proximity to the Sun; to understand that there was a basic mathematical relationship between the length of time to complete an orbit and their distance from the Sun.

There's no easy answer to why Kepler was so compelled to tie his theory to his data, or, as Sagan puts it, to "combine imagination with observation." Perhaps it was his unwavering respect for Tycho Brahe's data. Or a quirk in his analytical mind. Or that the reformation dramatically altered the validity of sacred, unalterable truths.

Kepler's Astronomia Nova

Casey Dreier

Kepler's Astronomia Nova
Johannes Kepler's book, first edition.

Regardless of why, the important thing is that he did. It was this connection of theory to the real world that opened the door for Newton, born 12 years after Kepler died, to run with the concept. Starting with the idea that mathematics describes the patterns of nature, he developed the concept of gravity, uniting Earthly forces with the previously impregnable heavens. Without delving into too much historical speculation, I'd hazard to state that Newton would not have developed as much as he did without Kepler's groundbreaking work.

The show does a decent job of showing Kepler's story. The historical reenactments are probably a little too clean for that day and age (literally, Kepler didn't like to bathe), and Brahe's golden nose could use a little more work, but the story is well-told and compelling. It ends on a down note as Kepler wanders in the countryside, an old man who never achieved his dream of discovering the true geometrical theory of the universe. But as I said before, it's actually a beautiful story. He triumphed over the age he lived in. He set in motion a series of events that ultimately did more to reduce misery in the world than anyone could have dreamt of. He began the technological revolution.

Technology, of course, depends on science that comes from careful observation. The concept of collecting data and matching it to theory is now so ingrained to us that it's easy to forget that this had to be invented. Sagan calls Kepler the "spark that started the scientific revolution," but I think that's not quite right. Copernicus was the spark. Kepler was the first bright flame - both in spirit and intellect - that tore through the desiccated husk of medieval thought, allowing the mind to be reborn.

Stray Observations

  • Kepler was right in the middle of the The Thirty Years' War, which by some estimates massacred the local population in rates similar to World War II. It was a nasty time to be alive. But there's something beautiful about his revolutionary ideas springing forth from such a miserable period in human history - inspiring, really. Even in the darkest times of our civilization, the mind can still flourish, though rarely.
  • My wife points out (correctly) that the episode barely spends any time with Tycho Brahe, without whom Kepler would never had had the data necessary to make his discoveries. Also, Tycho would be a lot more fun to hang out with.
  • Statistically speaking there's a planet with a civilization that never progressed beyond medieval physics.The distributions of the orbits of its sibling planets just happened to match some arbitrary, pleasing geometric pattern.
  • In the quick detour to the ruins of the Anasazi people in New Mexico we have another answer to the "so what" question. Astronomy was embedded into daily life, serving as timekeeper for major activities: planting, harvest, and religious rituals. It was deeply important to the lives of ancient peoples. How strange, in a way, that as our technology advanced our direct connection to the stars faded, ultimately going so far as to obscure their existence by the television-tuned-to-a-dead-channel glow of our urban skies.
  • There is a fundamental irony to Kepler's life. He labored for decades to understand the motions of the planets, discovering along the way his three laws of planetary motion, all in the service of his incorrect thesis that the spacing of the planetary orbits was determined by the shapes of the five perfect solids. He created the science of astronomy almost by accident.
  • A great book about Kepler is Arthur Koestler's The Sleepwalkers (though I assume not 100% historically accurate, it's a joy to read).
  • Tycho's dwarf's name was Jepp.

Quotes

  • "A reminder of the 40,000 generations of thinking men and women who preceded us, about whom we know nothing, upon whom our society is based."
  • "The desire to be connected with the cosmos reflects a profound reality. We are connected, not in the trivial ways that the pseudoscience of astrology promises, but in the deepest ways."
  • "These are known as laws, some of which are already known to us."
« Episode 2: One Voice in
the Cosmic Fugue
Episode 4: Heaven & Hell »
 
See other posts from October 2013

 

Or read more blog entries about: product review, history, fun

Comments:

Torbj??rn Larsson: 10/29/2013 06:05 CDT

By now the quality of the series shine through the light of Sagan's personality. Three great episodes in a row, this time used to tell an individual's story and its consequences for the world. I was surprised by the amount of time devoted to religion, maybe that is my european perspective speaking, but it worked. I'm less certain about the use of speculations about mostly Kepler's individual motivations and how well they can be supported by the historical record. And it is a problematic issue to try to analyze a historical setting even with source records, since the cultural environment can be incomprehensible for modern eyes. But again, it works and may be necessary to ground the episode. I would say this against any historical series I guess, so while it must be mentioned, it isn't consequential. I reacted strongly to Sagan's use of "according to precise mathematical laws", because it deifies and cements the platonist dualism of mathematicians. I would rather see 'according to physical laws that follows mathematical patterns'. But that's me speaking, not Sagan and his times. The episodes so far, and the extensive writeups and reflections here, certainly prompt me to see the full series. Can barely wait for the next episode!

Dan Cook: 10/29/2013 07:31 CDT

I remember really liking Tycho Brahe’s nose as a kid. This time around it became more of a symbol of excess and self-destruction. When it got to the part about him dying from over consumption my wife and i put down the cosmos and switched to Michelob Ultra. :)

Dan Cook: 10/29/2013 07:41 CDT

Also, thanks for recommending the Arthur Koestler books.

Dan Cook: 11/02/2013 04:06 CDT

I enjoyed revisiting this episode, but I was left with a nagging concern. Does the catalyst of modern science work so well that it burns up aesthetics in the process or should the beauty inherent in the data truly be enough? http://cosmosredux.blogspot.com/2013/11/episode-3-harmony-of-worlds.html

Dan Cook: 11/02/2013 04:18 CDT

@Torbjorn Your comment about the platonist dualism of mathematicians made me think of Darron Aronofsky's movie PI, which led me down the path of thinking about how many discussions I've had with friends about why PI is the value that it is and how all of mathematics seems arbitrary and made up. Frustrating.

Supernaut: 11/04/2013 02:33 CST

"Sagan calls Kepler the "spark that started the scientific revolution," but I think that's not quite right. Copernicus was the spark. Kepler was the first bright flame.." Yes, I'd tend to agree with this observation. Coincidentally, the already-mentioned Koestler' "The Watershed" book is great, and I will have to read again some time. Also, "The Book that Nobody Read" by Gingerich is about Copernicus' "De Revolutionibus", but of course also talks a lot about Copernicus. Great Cosmos episode!

Peter Martinson: 11/08/2013 08:32 CST

Here's a funny irony - Arthur Koestler set up an institution at the University of Edinburgh to study paranormal activity. It's now called the "Koestler Parapsychology Unit."

Leave a Comment:

You must be logged in to submit a comment. Log in now.
Facebook Twitter Email RSS AddThis

Blog Search

JOIN THE
PLANETARY SOCIETY

Our Curiosity Knows No Bounds!

Become a member of The Planetary Society and together we will create the future of space exploration.

Join Us

Featured Images

NGC 6365

M29
Globular cluster M4
Caprock and sand ripples, Curiosity sol 679
More Images

Featured Video

View Larger »

Fly to an Asteroid!

Travel to Bennu on the OSIRIS-REx spacecraft!

Send your name

Join the New Millennium Committee

Let’s invent the future together!

Become a Member

Connect With Us

Facebook! Twitter! Google+ and more…
Continue the conversation with our online community!