Help Shape the Future of Space Exploration

Join The Planetary Society Now  arrow.png

Join our eNewsletter for updates & action alerts

    Please leave this field empty

Emily Martin

Boulders and Ponds on 433 Eros

Posted by Emily Martin

13-12-2010 12:10 CST

Topics: asteroids, NEAR, explaining science, asteroid 433 Eros

Emily Martin is a former student of my former grad school officemate who is now a PhD student in the Terrestrial and Planetary Structural Geology and Geomechanics program at the University of Idaho. She is researching the fracture development on Enceladus, with an emphasis on strike-slip faults and crater-related fractures. This is her second guest post summarizing a recent paper in her field of study; her first was on Selk crater on Titan. I'm glad she found time to send another writeup! Anyone else out there care to give this exercise a try? Any professors want to assign this activity to your grad students? --ESL

There is really cool geology being explored on large, oddly shaped asteroids. The Near Earth Asteroid Rendezvous (NEAR) mission (later renamed NEAR Shoemaker) reached 433 Eros in 2000, and one of the exciting results was the discovery of features called "ponds". 433 Eros is the only place in the solar system so far where they are found! I read about Eros' ponds in a paper called "Boulders and ponds on the Asteroid 433 Eros," by Andrew Dombard and three co-authors in the most recent Icarus.

I had to do some background research, because when I first picked up this paper, I was completely unfamiliar with 433 Eros. It was discovered by Carl Witt in 1898, and was the first near-Earth object to be discovered. Near-Earth, in the case of Eros, means an orbital distance that averages 1.45 astronomical units from the sun. 433 Eros was also the first near-Earth asteroid to be visited by spacecraft.

Eros rotation animation


Eros rotation animation
One full rotation of the asteroid Eros as seen by the Near Earth Asteroid Rendezvous (NEAR; later renamed NEAR Shoemaker) spacecraft on February 16, 2000, two days after its arrival. View more information here.

One difficulty with studying asteroids is trying to mosaic images together of a body that is so oddly shaped and project them on a flat surface. Spheres also don't project on a flat surface either, but there are a variety of map projections we use to change how we look at the images depending on what we are looking at.

Map of Eros

USGS / Phil Stooke, University of Western Ontario

Map of Eros
Map of the asteroid 433 Eros created by Phil Stooke using images acquired by the NEAR Shoemaker spacecraft in 2000.

This paper is trying to understand how ponds form and how they are related to the boulders that are found inside them (I envisioned an egg in a bird's nest). "Ponds" are flat-floored depressions bound by sharp embayments, usually less than 60 meters across, but they can be as big as 210 meters across. "Boulders" are harder to define, because they are small and near the image resolution. They are identified as localized features with steep, positive topography, and usually have debris aprons skirting them.

Ponds on Eros

NASA / JHUAPL / Dombard et al.

Ponds on Eros
Three different views of "ponds" on Eros. (a) contains multiple ponds (black arrows), the middle one of which has several boulders lying within the depression. (b) shows a pond exhibiting a characteristic flat, smooth texture, containing a boulder with a debris apron (white arrows). (c) shows a pond with several boulders and associated debris aprons. (NEAR-Shoemaker MSI images: (a) 1479,32,871; (b) 156-,87,851; (c) 1560,83,231.)

Dombard and his co-authors created a model for how ponds and boulders form based on their observations. Ponds are found in places that get the most direct sunlight and are clustered around Eros' equator. Color images from the NEAR Shoemaker spacecraft showed that ponds were also slightly bluer than anything else. I've broken down their formation model into four stages:

  1. Ponds form in pre-existing local depressions.
  2. Boulders are thrown into depressions in the form of ejecta from a few large impacts, most likely the impact that formed Shoemaker Regio (a ~10km wide divot in 433 Eros's side). This means that the boulders on the surface are samples of Eros's interior!
  3. Boulders erode through thermal erosion.
  4. Eroded boulder material is flattened into the pond bottom by seismic shaking.
How boulders erode into ponds on Eros

Dombard et al. 2010

How boulders erode into ponds on Eros
An explanation for how ponds form on Eros: (a) a large impact tosses a boulder into a local depression. (b) thermal cycling (the rapid temperature changes from day to night on airless Eros) weathers the boulder, breaking off grains that get deposited around it as debris aprons. (c) seismic shaking from other impacts jiggles the material inside the depression, causing it to smooth out and fill the floor. The buried (and thus preserved) remnant of the original boulder is indicated with dashed lines.

This is where it becomes really important to know that 433 Eros is an S-type asteroid -- which is where we think stony meteorites come from. Ponds and boulders are mostly found in the hottest places on 433 Eros, but these places also get very cold when they are not receiving sunlight, just like the airless Moon. The result is extreme temperature changes creating microscopic cracks that get bigger in high stress environments.

Where does the stress come from? When something gets hot, it expands. When surface layers of the boulders are warmed by the sun during the daytime, chondrules (small mineral grains) within the boulder get squeezed by the heat-driven expansion. The opposite will happen during periods of nighttime, colder temperatures. After many hot and cold cycles, the outer layer of the boulder is weakened enough to fall off at a rate of about 1 meter of boulder material every 10-100 million years. The erosion rate -- which is short compared to the age of the solar system, but still a reasonably long period in the geologic lifetime of an asteroid -- can also explain why there are some ponds that do not have boulders in them.

I already mentioned that so far, ponds have only been found on 433 Eros. Dawn will visit two much larger asteroids, Vesta and Ceres. Will it find ponds there? Dombard and his co-authors suspect Ceres is too icy for ponds to exist, and if they occur on Vesta, they will be much larger. I will now be paying very close attention to images coming back from Dawn when it arrives at Vesta next summer!

See other posts from December 2010


Or read more blog entries about: asteroids, NEAR, explaining science, asteroid 433 Eros


Leave a Comment:

You must be logged in to submit a comment. Log in now.
Facebook Twitter Email RSS AddThis

Blog Search

Essential Advocacy

Our Advocacy Program provides each Society member a voice in the process.

Funding is critical. The more we have, the more effective we can be, translating into more missions, more science, and more exploration.


Featured Images

Comparison of Schiaparelli and Opportunity landing locations
Mars Reconnaissance Orbiter Context Camera image of Curiosity landing site
Schiaparelli landing site, after landing attempt
Ewen Whitaker
More Images

Featured Video

The Planetary Post - Star Trek 50th Anniversary

Watch Now

Space in Images

Pretty pictures and
awe-inspiring science.

See More

Join The Planetary Society

Let’s explore the cosmos together!

Become a Member

Connect With Us

Facebook, Twitter, YouTube and more…
Continue the conversation with our online community!