Help Shape the Future of Space Exploration

Join The Planetary Society Now  arrow.png

Join our eNewsletter for updates & action alerts

    Please leave this field empty
Blogs

Headshot of Emily Lakdawalla

Seven Mars spacecraft attempted observations of comet Siding Spring. How did they go?

Posted by Emily Lakdawalla

03-11-2014 16:03 CST

Topics: Mars Orbiter Mission (MOM), comet Siding Spring, MAVEN, Curiosity (Mars Science Laboratory), Mars Reconnaissance Orbiter, pretty pictures, Mars Odyssey, comets, Opportunity, Spirit, Mars Express, Mars Exploration Rovers, Mars

It's been two weeks since comet Siding Spring passed close by Mars, and six of the seven Mars spacecraft have now checked in with quick looks at their images of the encounter. None of the spacecraft photos of the comet is visually spectacular -- there are no enormous fireballs streaking across Martian skies. What the released images do show us is that this is a terrific data set taken from very close range on an Oort cloud comet; over the coming months and years, we'll enjoy the fruits of careful scientific investigation of a unique data set.

And it's worth taking a moment to appreciate how we got these photos. A year ago, we discovered a teeny tiny object that had never visited the inner solar system before; we predicted that it would pass by another planet; we already had five spacecraft at that planet, and two more preparing to launch; and we commanded all these autonomous robots to catch the comet as it flashed by at 55 kilometers per second.

Comet Siding Spring from Mars Exploration Rover Opportunity

NASA / JPL / Cornell / ASU / TAMU

Comet Siding Spring from Mars Exploration Rover Opportunity
A comet fresh from the Oort cloud visited Mars on October 19, 2014. Opportunity pointed her cameras before sunset and then woke up to take this photo at 3:19 a.m. local time on sol 3817, about 2.5 hours before its closest approach to Mars. The comet makes a slightly elongated smudge across the sky -- but it is elongated in a different direction than the streaked stars in this long exposure, indicating the comet's apparent rapid motion across the Martian sky.

The very best photos of the close approach of the comet to Mars were actually not taken from any of the Mars spacecraft; they were taken by astronomers on Earth, mostly amateurs. Here are three of my favorites, taken by three different amateur astronomers from telescopes at Siding Spring Observatory, where the comet was discovered last year.

Comet Siding Spring and Mars -- from Siding Spring Observatory (James Willinghan)

James Willinghan

Comet Siding Spring and Mars -- from Siding Spring Observatory (James Willinghan)
Comet Siding Spring (center) and Mars (brilliant object at upper right) seen on October 18, 2014 at 10:25 UT, 32 hours before the comet's closest approach. Image acquired from iTelescope Siding Spring, Australia
Comet Siding Spring just hours before its close approach to Mars (Damian Peach)

SEN / Damian Peach

Comet Siding Spring just hours before its close approach to Mars (Damian Peach)
Less than eight hours from closest approach, Siding Spring's green coma is dwarfed by the brilliant blaze of Mars.
Comet Siding Spring after its close approach to Mars (Rolando Ligustri)

Rolando Ligustri

Comet Siding Spring after its close approach to Mars (Rolando Ligustri)
Comet Siding Spring (just above center) and Mars (brilliant object to lower left) seen on October 20, 2014 at 09:47 UT, hours after the comet's closest approach. Image acquired from iTelescope Siding Spring, Australia. The bright star at upper right is 51 Ophiuchi.

For more amateur views, check the Bad Astronomer's and Universe Today's galleries, or try the Realtime Comet Gallery at spaceweather.com.

All five Mars orbiters successfully performed the tricky observations that they were commanded to do, but not all five produced results. Three of the five (Mars Reconnaissance Orbiter, MAVEN, and Mars Express) definitely detected the comet. Sadly, the comet was not bright enough in infrared wavelengths for Odyssey to detect it with its THEMIS instrument, Phil Christensen has told me. I've heard nothing about ISRO's Mars Orbiter images, but I presume we would have heard something by now if the comet were detectable in them.

It turns out that one of the first spacecraft to detect the comet was the MAVEN orbiter, newly arrived at Mars. It captured this view of the hydrogen surrounding the comet two days away from its approach to Mars:

MAVEN view of comet Siding Spring at Mars

NASA / LASP / University of Colorado

MAVEN view of comet Siding Spring at Mars
MAVEN captured this ultraviolet image of hydrogen surrounding comet C/2013 A1 Siding Spring on October 17, 2014, two days before the comet's closest approach to Mars, When the comet was 8.5 million kilometers away. The image shows sunlight that has been scattered by atomic hydrogen. Comets are surrounded by a huge cloud of atomic hydrogen because water vaporizes from the icy nucleus, and solar ultraviolet light breaks it apart into hydrogen and oxygen. Hydrogen atoms scatter solar ultraviolet light, and it was this light that was imaged by the Imaging Ultraviolet Spectrograph.

You can see hydrogen out to about half a degree away from the comet nucleus, which was about 150,000 kilometers. The MAVEN team points out that this is comparable to the distance of the comet's closest approach to Mars, which means that hydrogen atoms were slamming in to Mars' atmosphere at relative speeds of 56 kilometers per second. This photo hints at the possibility of a pretty interesting data set from MAVEN.

The most anticipated photos of the comet were those of Mars Reconnaissance Orbiter's HiRISE camera, which was the only one that could hope to resolve the comet's nucleus. HiRISE was actually able to spot the comet 12 days before it arrived at Mars, and it's a good thing they did, because without those early photos, they would not have been pointing in exactly the right spot to image the comet when it got much closer. They haven't released the photo taken 12 days before closest approach, yet.

Fortunately, HiRISE did get the necessary update on the comet's position and successfully imaged the comet at very high resolution. But the photos don't show as many pixels across the comet as predicted, because the comet turned out to be smaller than predicted.

Mars Reconnaissance Orbiter HiRISE spies comet Siding Spring

NASA / JPL / UA

Mars Reconnaissance Orbiter HiRISE spies comet Siding Spring
HiRISE caught these photos of comet Siding Spring on the spacecraft's last Mars orbit before the comet's closest approach, around 17:00 UTC on October 19. This composite image shows two versions of each of two of the best HiRISE images of the comet. Shown at top are images with the full dynamic range, showing the nucleus and bright coma near the nucleus. Shown at bottom are versions where the fainter outer coma is brightened, saturating the inner region. The images at left and right were taken about nine minutes apart. The comet turned out to be smaller than predicted.

Although the comet's small size is a little disappointing for the images, it's actually quite an exciting scientific result, probably. The size of unresolved solar system objects is estimated by taking its absolute magnitude (which can be measured reasonably precisely) and assuming an albedo, or reflectiveness, of its surface. All the comets we've ever seen up close are exceedingly dark, with albedos around 5 percent, give or take a couple percent. The fact that Siding Spring turned out to be smaller than predicted means we guessed its albedo wrong. Its surface is more reflective than we predicted. Which is wonderful, because it's consistent with the hypothesis that comets are usually dark because the Sun has baked away brighter ices, and that they start out their cometary lives much brighter. So we may have just learned something about the nature of bodies that are too far away from the Sun for us to see. (I am hedging all of my language here because I would like to see a bright comet nucleus albedo confirmed by more quantitative analysis and, ideally, evidence from another one of the spacecraft.)

I find the HiRISE images to be a little bit difficult to interpret. One important piece of information is that the phase angle of the observation is about 110 degrees, so we're seeing the nucleus of the comet in a crescent phase. That is, most of the nucleus of the comet that is in the field of view is actually the night side. The bright blob is not the nucleus; the nucleus is about a quarter of the bright blob, and about three quarters dark pixels next to the bright blob. The sunlit crescent of the comet is hard to differentiate from the brightest inner part of the coma.

For comparison, here is a Deep Impact image of comet Tempel 1 taken after their flyby in 2005. The phase angle here is also about 110 degrees; you can see how it could be hard to tell the nucleus from the coma, especially with a much lower-resolution image. It's not a perfect comparison because Tempel 1 was not as active as Siding Spring -- it isn't the coma you're seeing here, it's the ejecta from Deep Impact's impact. Siding Spring's coma wouldn't emanate from just one spot on the comet's surface; it would be coming from numerous locations, and it may just blend in to the nucleus in the HiRISE photos.

Deep Impact "lookback" image of Tempel 1

NASA/JPL-Caltech/UMD

Deep Impact "lookback" image of Tempel 1
This "lookback" image was captured by Deep Impact's high-resolution imager as it receded from comet Tempel 1 early today. The bright spot is not an incandescent flare; it represents dust in the ejecta curtain spraying out from the comet, which is backlit by the Sun.

I've heard that Mars Reconnaissance Orbiter's Context Camera also successfully detected the comet, in a ridealong observation with HiRISE. They haven't released the photo, I'm assuming (without having seen it) because it's nothing more than a speck -- it would be underwhelming.

Mars Reconnaissance orbiter CRISM got a really good look at the coma. CRISM is an imaging spectrometer; it doesn't have the sharp spatial detail of HiRISE, but every single pixel in a CRISM image is a full visible and near-infrared spectrum at that point, which can be interpreted by spectroscopists to infer the presence and sometimes the abundance of different molecules. The images below don't tell you all that, but they show color that varies from place to place, which means that this is a really rich data set that is going to tell us something very specific about the comet's constitution, once the scientists have had time to interpret the data.

Comet Siding Spring from Mars Reconnaissance Orbiter CRISM

NASA / JPL / JHUAPL

Comet Siding Spring from Mars Reconnaissance Orbiter CRISM
CRISM acquired the first image (left) at 18:16 UTC, just prior to the comet's closest approach to Mars at 18:27. The second image was taken 37 minutes later. The comet -- traveling at 55 kilometers per second -- had traversed one-third of the way across the Martian sky between those imaging times. The scale of the left image is approximately four kilometers per pixel; for the right image, it is about five kilometers per pixel. The images show the inner part of the cloud of dust, called the coma, that is generated around the nucleus by the warmth of the sun. The solid nucleus itself is not resolved. CRISM observed 107 different wavelengths of light in each pixel. Here, only three colors are shown.

For CRISM geeks: The three colors used in the image above represent the amount of signal in three regions of the visible and near-infrared spectrum. For each pixel, the median of 850-980 nanometers is displayed as red, 720-850 nanometers as green, and 500-630 nanometers as blue. There is rich signal in each one of those pixels, just waiting to be decoded into compositional information.

The last orbiter that I have been waiting for is Mars Express. Its High Resolution Stereo Camera (HRSC) also took photos of the comet, and one set was finally released yesterday. Here it is, a six-image animation of photos taken with the Super-Resolution Camera, the small, slighly out-of-focus framing camera that is a small part of the HRSC instrument.

HRSC animation of comet Siding Spring

ESA / DLR / FU Berlin

HRSC animation of comet Siding Spring
This animation is composed of six Super-Resolution Camera images of comet Siding Spring taken about 17 seconds apart on the spacecraft's orbit 13710, one Mars Express orbit after the comet's closest approach. The resolution of the images is about 17 kilometers per pixel.

I included this animation in the blog post for completeness, but I have to admit I don't really know how to interpret it. My brain really wants to see an irregularly-shaped comet nucleus tumbling in space. But that is most definitely not what the animation is showing us. Each pixel in the image is 17 kilometers across -- it was taken on the orbit after closest approach, so the comet was already pretty far away. We know from HiRISE that the comet nucleus is less than a kilometer across, so its light only contributes to about one thousandth of one pixel's area in the SRC animation. Everything we see in that blob moving across the image is from the coma. Even so, I can't tell you what I'm looking at, because the pixels are either black or white -- it's a one-bit animation. I don't understand why that is. The one thing this image does tell you is that Mars Express was successful in targeting the comet; hitting the SRC field of view is no easy task. Which bodes well for the other experiments that Mars Express performed.

There's one more spacecraft that attempted observations: Curiosity. For Curiosity it was hard to see the comet because it appeared in very bright twilight, close to the horizon, and a week's worth of rising dust activity made the twilight even brighter than it has usually been. The comet's there, but it's just a single pixel, almost invisible unless you enlarge the photo all the way (click through twice and look close to the upper left corner). But the images that it took to make that observation are beautiful all on their own, even without containing any comet in them.

Curiosity sol 783 sunset panorama containing Siding Spring

NASA / JPL / MSSS / James Sorenson

Curiosity sol 783 sunset panorama containing Siding Spring
Curiosity took the photos for this panorama just after sunset on sol 783, at 6:11 local time. The twilight sky is still bright thanks to lots of dust in the atmosphere. Near the extreme upper left corner of this panorama is a single bright pixel representing comet Siding Spring, which had just passed close by Mars a couple of hours earlier. (The comet is difficult to spot unless you enlarge the photo to its full resolution.) This photo was taken at about 21:10 UT on October 19; closest approach occurred at 18:27.

This post just represents a smattering of the huge amounts of data that were collected by orbiters and rovers during the encounter. It'll take months or, more likely, a couple of years for all the results to come out. There will probably be a dedicated session at a future science meeting about the Siding Spring encounter with Mars, and after scientists have presented and discussed their individual work there, they will prepare papers for a special issue of a peer-reviewed journal covering all the different spacecraft's findings. It's not a fast process, but it's a thorough one. We have the data in hand, but it will be a while before we learn what it has to tell us about the nature of comet Siding Spring.

 
See other posts from November 2014

 

Or read more blog entries about: Mars Orbiter Mission (MOM), comet Siding Spring, MAVEN, Curiosity (Mars Science Laboratory), Mars Reconnaissance Orbiter, pretty pictures, Mars Odyssey, comets, Opportunity, Spirit, Mars Express, Mars Exploration Rovers, Mars

Comments:

Jonathan Ursin: 11/04/2014 12:25 CST

Nice compilation.

CosmosQuest: 11/04/2014 12:23 CST

Emily, Nice summary of the various spaceprobe imagery of the Siding-Spring comet. I have to concur that the most difficult to interpret is the odd 6-image animation from the Mars Express orbiter with its HRSC camera. What blows me away is that all 6 of the light images we see from ( as you rightly surmise must be of the coma and not the nucleus) have very crisp, sharp-edges to them ! How can this be since the coma is always a quite diffuse and nebulous thing. Thanks for the update Emily. Look forward to your participation in ESA's online briefing on G+ Friday! Hope you ask some great questions, as usual.

Mark: 11/04/2014 01:45 CST

thanks a lot Emily, we've been waiting for this for two long weeks. The results are, I think, as scientists have expected. This was an unplanned encounter, using spacecraft which were not designed for this purpose and we've made the best of it. A few pixels here, an over-exposed blob there but at least, a comet observed from Mars. Where I take exception is the media hype, including here, which suggested to the public a massive, flashing bolide careering across the Martian sky, trailing a long white tale. It is pleasing that BBC and SkyNews pick up the story and bring it to public awareness, but the over-egging of the pudding is unnecessary. Why do we do this? Comet ISON, Blood moons, super moons, minor meteor showers etc. are all 'awesome' or 'extraordinary'. The fact is, they're not! The average guy in the street would not notice a supermoon from a normal full moon, so why do journalists do it? I'd love to know.

Brian: 11/05/2014 10:41 CST

CosmosQuest, I believe the crispness of the image is due to its one-bit color depth (black and white), as Emily noted. The question is why it doesn't contain more color or greyscale information.

Jakub: 11/06/2014 01:41 CST

The measures of HiRISE actually doesn't mean that albedo is wrong. We never captured pure nucleus before, the scientific methods that estimating nucleus size are known to have large errors and what is cause is unknown. The MRO team should be able to directly measure comet albedo from HiRISE picture so we will see if its reflectivity is higher then not.

Premnath Kudva: 11/15/2014 06:03 CST

Finally MOM has released some images of Siding Spring on their FB page. Rather it shared the image that ISRO posted on their FB page. https://www.facebook.com/ISRO/photos/a.1448404935382864.1073741828.1448364408720250/1571634429726580/?type=1&theater

Leave a Comment:

You must be logged in to submit a comment. Log in now.
Facebook Twitter Email RSS AddThis

Blog Search

Essential Advocacy

Our Advocacy Program 
provides each Society member 
a voice in the process.



Funding is critical. The more 
we have, the more effective 
we can be, translating into more 
missions, more science, 
and more exploration.

Donate

Featured Images

Viking Lander 2 Camera 1 Frost (Low Resolution Color)
Viking Lander 2 Camera 2 frost (Low Resolution Color)
Viking Lander 2 Camera 2 (Native) High Resolution Color Mosaic
Viking Lander 2 Camera 1 Noon High Resolution Color Mosiac
More Images

Featured Video

The Planetary Post - A Visit To JPL

Watch Now

Space in Images

Pretty pictures and
awe-inspiring science.

See More

Join the New Millennium Committee

Let’s invent the future together!

Become a Member

Connect With Us

Facebook, Twitter, YouTube and more…
Continue the conversation with our online community!