Help Shape the Future of Space Exploration

Join The Planetary Society Now  arrow.png

Join our eNewsletter for updates & action alerts

    Please leave this field empty
Facebook Twitter Email RSS AddThis

Bill Dunford Profile Thumbnail

A Sky Full of Stars

Posted By Bill Dunford

09-03-2015 8:03 CDT

Topics: Enceladus, NASA lunar missions before 2005, Cassini, Iapetus, Voyager 1 and 2, Chang'E program, Curiosity (Mars Science Laboratory), Saturn's rings, pics of Earth by planetary missions, pretty pictures, Neptune's rings, Earth, the Moon, Mars

Where are the stars?

This is one of the most common questions I hear about images from deep space. For example, look at this recent picture postcard of the Earth and the moon sent by China's Chang'e 5 spacecraft.

Earth and the Moon from Chang'e 5 T1


Earth and the Moon from Chang'e 5 T1
The Chang'e 5 test vehicle captured this beautiful view of Earth over the far side of the Moon on October 28, 2014.

It's a striking portrait of a handsome couple. But if they are floating in space, where are the stars? Shouldn't we see thousands of stars in the background, maybe even the Milky Way? This solid wall of black sky in so many images from space is the source of confusion--not to mention conspiracy theories. 

The answer is pretty straightforward. The stars are there. In fact, if you could physically ride along with Chang'e or any of the other spacecraft you'd see the stars in all their glory. The issue is a photographic one. Cameras have a much more difficult time than your eyes do when it comes capturing widely different levels of light. It's simply very difficult, often impossible, to correctly expose a photograph when the scene contains both very bright areas and very dark ones. A simple experiment: try taking a picture of a bright moon in a dark sky. Chances are, even though you can see both the moon and the stars with your eyes, if you've set up your camera to expose the picture so that the moon shows up clearly, you won't see any stars near the moon's bright disc in your picture.

So when the Apollo astronauts were bouncing across the moon's brilliant horizon the sky behind them looked black. The same is true for images from robotic spacecraft in deep space: Saturn is dazzling, not only aesthetically but physically as well. 

All that said, there are exceptions. Sometimes, those exceptions make for the most amazing images. When conditions are just right the stars do show up, as in this view of Saturn's moon Enceladus from the Cassini spacecraft.

Enceladus among stars


Enceladus among stars
Extremely unusual circumstances were required to get this shot of Enceladus floating in front of a field of stars. The Cassini spacecraft is flying in space, of course, and regularly captures images of star fields. It also regularly captures images of Enceladus. But Enceladus is so brightly reflective that, under normal circumstances, it is impossible to see both features on Enceladus' surface and a dense field of stars in the same image. To see Enceladus' surface, the camera team would select a short exposure setting; to see the stars, they would select a long exposure setting. This photo is possible because Enceladus was actually in Saturn's shadow when it was taken; the only light reaching its surface (and reflecting from there to Cassini's camera) is sunlight that has first been reflected off of Saturn or its rings. A long exposure revealed both Enceladus' surface and the background field of stars.

This shot was possible because the moon is not lit by brilliant sunshine, but only by reflected light from Saturn.

Here's another look at Enceladus. Here, the camera was set so that the sunlit side of the moon is awash in overexposed light, but the plumes from its famous ice geysers and the stars in the background show up just fine. As Cassini tracks Enceladus over the course of several photographs, the moon moves in its orbit and the stars appear to rush by.

Enceladus Amid the Stars

NASA / JPL / SSI / Animation by Bill Dunford

Enceladus Amid the Stars
Saturn's moon Enceladus, with its intriguing ice geysers, seems to be rocketing through space in this series of images taken by Cassini.

Even farther out in the solar system, the gas giant planet Neptune is graced with a whisper-thin set of rings. When the Voyager 2 mission passed by, controllers set the cameras to expose for the faint ring arcs, allowing the stars to appear as well.

Rings and Stars


Rings and Stars
The faint rings of Neptune against a sea of stars. An image from Voyager 2 in 1989.

And one of my favorites, a view of Saturn's odd, two-sided moon Iapetus. Again, we're looking at the moon's night side, illuminated only by reflected Saturnshine. The long exposure has stretched the stars into a shower of light. 

A Storm of Stars


A Storm of Stars
In 2004, Cassini observed Saturn's moon Iapetus. Over the course of about a minute and a half, the camera captured reflected Saturnshine on the night side of Iapetus, and the apparent motion of stars in the background as the moon moved through the sky. The stars appear as streaks; the single dots are noise from radiation hitting the camera sensor.

Stargazing in deep space has its practical uses, too. One way to precisely measure Saturn's rings is to watch when they pass in front of a bright star. As the star shines through the translucent circles of icy ring particles, scientists note how it flickers bright then dim, allowing them to refine their model of the ring's properties.

Antares tours Saturn's rings

NASA / JPL / SSI / Emily Lakdawalla

Antares tours Saturn's rings
Cassini watched as a bright star, Antares, passed behind Saturn's rings in this series of 15 photos captured on January 3, 2008. It is brighter where the rings are more transparent, and dims where the rings are more opaque.

When we look at the sky from Earth, the planets themselves look like bright stars, simply because they're so far away. The same is true of spacecraft observing planets other than the ones they're currently orbiting. Here's a view of Venus from the Clementine mission to the moon. From its vantage point near the Earth, Clementine's cameras saw Venus as the bright evening star we know so well. 

The Moon and the Evening Star

NASA / Naval Research Laboratory / Bill Dunford

The Moon and the Evening Star
One of the star tracker cameras onboard the Clementine orbiter captured the moon and Venus, which was so bright it somewhat overwhelmed the image sensor.

The same is true for other planets.

On January 31, 2014, about an hour and a half after sunset, a robot on Mars raised its head. It lifted its camera eyes from the desert floor, and stared off toward the west. There, a darkening sky spread out above a line of silhouetted mountains. In the perfectly clean air, the stars began to ignite one by one. The brightest was actually two stars, a brilliant white gem and a smaller spark just below it.

But they weren’t stars at all. They were the Earth and the Moon.

Mars may be an alien world, but if you went there and looked up at the night sky you’d see something that might surprise you: most of the stars would look exactly the same. The distance between the Earth and Mars isn’t nearly enough to change the perspective on the much more distant constellations. You’d see all the familiar sights, the Big Dipper and Orion and the Milky Way. The only difference in the sky, other than the sharp brilliance of everything seen through such thin air, would be that “extra” evening or morning star and its little companion.

You would look at that spark, and you would know you weren’t alone.

The Same Sky

Mars sky: NASA / JPL / MSSS / TAMU | Earth sky: Bill Dunford

The Same Sky
Earth from Mars, Mars from Earth. Left: the Earth and the Moon in the evening sky of Mars, as seen by the Curiosity rover. Right: Mars rising over Salt Lake City.
See other posts from March 2015


Read more blog entries about: Enceladus, NASA lunar missions before 2005, Cassini, Iapetus, Voyager 1 and 2, Chang'E program, Curiosity (Mars Science Laboratory), Saturn's rings, pics of Earth by planetary missions, pretty pictures, Neptune's rings, Earth, the Moon, Mars


Jody: 03/09/2015 08:38 CDT

Maybe our spacecraft have to take some tips from earth bound photographers and start taking HDR (multiple exposure) images to capture both stars and the planets.

Pete Jackson: 03/09/2015 09:35 CDT

Thanks, Bill, for some really amazing images showing the stars as well as planetary and satellite surfaces. I really enjoyed this.

Bob Ware: 03/12/2015 09:55 CDT

Beautiful! Thanks! The last photo comparison is priceless! This article reminded me of an APOLLO era shot during the TAD phase right after the turn-a-round was completed. One of 17's crew shot the LM in the adapter and since they were facing 'across light' you saw a multitude of stars in the photo. Using the shutter speed properly as you described the astronaut captured a great photo of Challenger.

Leave a Comment:

You must be logged in to submit a comment. Log in now.

Space in Images

Pretty pictures and
awe-inspiring science.

See More

Join The Planetary Society

Let’s explore the cosmos together!

Become a Member

Connect With Us

Facebook, Twitter, YouTube and more…
Continue the conversation with our online community!