Help Shape the Future of Space Exploration

Join The Planetary Society Now  arrow.png

Join our eNewsletter for updates & action alerts

    Please leave this field empty
Facebook Twitter Email RSS AddThis

Ruth McAvinia

ExoMars: Long day’s journey into uncertainty

Posted By Ruth McAvinia

19-10-2016 15:04 CDT

Topics: mission status, ExoMars TGO, Mars

The European Space Agency has been “managing expectations” all day. It’s a euphemism every business employs for preparing people not to get what they wanted. “Underpromise and overdeliver” is also a popular phrase at ESA. But sometimes you must state your ambitions publicly, and the orbital insertion of the ExoMars Trace Gas Orbiter (TGO) and landing of the demonstration lander Schiaparelli was such a time. Recent NASA successes on Mars may have yielded the impression that landing there is easy. ESA have been underlining that it is not, nor has it been easy for their partners, Roscosmos.

ExoMars TGO and Schiaparelli approach Mars

ESA / ATG Medialab

ExoMars TGO and Schiaparelli approach Mars

First, the good news. The main part of the mission, the Trace Gas Orbiter, has been inserted into the correct orbit. It will look at the gases constituting less than 1% of the atmosphere, focusing especially on methane. ESA’s Mars Express has detected methane from orbit already, and Curiosity has seen it come and go from the surface. Its transient nature has puzzled planetary scientists. It shouldn’t persist in the atmosphere, implying that somehow it is being replenished by geological or biological processes undefined; nor should it vanish so quickly after it appears.

TGO’s safe arrival promises that the main science mission can proceed, and it will begin an aerobraking phase to change the shape of its orbit to a circular, science one in January. Once fully settled in, it will also become a relay point for NASA landers, fulfilling two of the three main objectives of ExoMars 2016.

The third objective was to demonstrate that Europe can land on Mars. On that front, the news is less positive. Both the data from Giant Metrewave Radio Telescope in Pune, India, and the data from Mars Express indicate a loss of signal at the same stage of the descent of the lander.

“That’s the bad news,” says Paolo Ferri, head of mission operations at ESA, “The fact that Pune and Mars Express lose the signal at the same time before the predicted time of touchdown.

“We will hear if there is some information from MRO [Mars Reconnaissance Orbiter] –but frankly I consider it unlikely that we get data from MRO. If we lost the signal before the landing, at least with the communications, why should MRO be able to communicate automatically?”

With no information coming from the lander, the key question is whether the lander itself is lost, or whether it’s just not able to communicate. There is more information about Schiaparelli’s fate on the way, with raw data expected around midnight Darmstadt time.

“TGO has been recording telemetry – it has recorded more than 20MB of data,” says Ferri. “TGO was doing a more important job, which was to get in orbit. So it was in a mode that doesn’t allow it to dump data.”

Switching into that mode, and sending back the data will take several hours.

“The estimation is that by midnight we should have the data here. Then these data have to be processed. It takes some time – it is a sampling of the radio signal. I’m pretty confident that this data – this telemetry – will tell us what action was interrupted when we lost the communication. I think, I am quite optimistic, that tomorrow morning with this data, we will know what happened,” Ferri says.

“It may mean we have some hope and some strategies to re-establish communication – I’m just speculating now. But we have very good chances to know tomorrow morning either to know that the lander is lost or to know the strategy to try to recover communication.”

If the lander is lost, so are the descent pictures it would have sent from the surface. As would be the final objective of the mission, the science that Schiaparelli would have been able to conduct during its time there – albeit a mission that was limited by battery life. If the lander is not transmitting, its battery life may be extended slightly, but its days are still very much numbered.

“Of course we hope we have a problem with the communications and not with the landing sequence. Certainly the problem happened very late in the sequence – there is a good chance that the parachute phase worked but at the moment we don’t know, it’s all speculation,”Ferri says.

The test of landing technologies was key to the next part of ExoMars – the 2020 lander and rover. But ESA so far are remaining optimistic about the future of the next mission.

“We need to learn how to land on Mars,” says Ferri, “And for me, whatever we understand of what happened, of course it helps to get to that objective.

“Whether we achieve it 100%, 95%, 90%, or 0%, but zero I think we can already exclude. The sequence was very long. But how far we have gone, I can’t say. I am pretty confident that we have enough data to do that.”

ESA Director General Jan Wörner sustained hope for the lander, and confidence in its contribution to the 2020 mission saying: “It is a big success for ESA – to fly to Mars is a very big challenge, to be in the orbit of Mars is a very big challenge.

“This spacecraft is a marvellous feat of engineering. Of course we also look at this part [Schiaparelli] this is a test part. We don’t know all the details but this is typical of a test. We did this to learn about how – using European technology – to land on Mars.”

“Our experts will look how to manage the next landing when we will go with the rover. I don’t close my hope right now that everything is fine.”

The next communication from ESA is expected at a news conference at 1000 CEST (0800 UTC, 04:00 EDT, 01:00 PDT) on Thursday. The most talented and experienced people on the mission have a long night ahead of them following their long day.


See other posts from October 2016


Read more blog entries about: mission status, ExoMars TGO, Mars


Red: 10/19/2016 04:18 CDT

A refreshingly informative post Ruth. No doubt I speak for many in how this feels too much like poor Beagle 2, and the abrupt cut off is similar to Mars Polar Lander too. However, as I know ESA would argue, it's not too late even with Schiaparelli's limited battery life. Hopefully clarity comes in the next 24 hours and ESA learns something for their next attempt.

Gene: 10/19/2016 04:33 CDT

While not all hope is yet lost for Schiaparelli, the realities of how difficult it is to achieve a successful Mars landing really tempers for me some of the recent excitement about humans stepping foot there in the next couple decades. The presence of human awareness during descent, and the options provided by ascent capability are certainly game changers, but I think we'd all feel more confidence if we could reliably, safely land these smaller craft.

Leave a Comment:

You must be logged in to submit a comment. Log in now.

Space in Images

Pretty pictures and
awe-inspiring science.

See More

Join The Planetary Society

Let’s explore the cosmos together!

Become a Member

Connect With Us

Facebook, Twitter, YouTube and more…
Continue the conversation with our online community!