Help Shape the Future of Space Exploration

Join The Planetary Society Now  arrow.png

Join our eNewsletter for updates & action alerts

    Please leave this field empty
Blogs

Jake Rosenthal

The Pioneer Plaque: Science as a Universal Language

Posted by Jake Rosenthal

20-01-2016 8:02 CST

Topics: history, Pioneer 10 and 11

In 1972, an attempt to contact extraterrestrial life was cast into space with the launch of the Pioneer 10 spacecraft. This space vehicle was designed to explore the environment of Jupiter, along with asteroids, solar winds, and cosmic rays. Among a succession of firsts achieved by the spacecraft, Pioneer 10 would attain enough velocity to escape the solar system. This tacked on yet another first: the possibility of the interception of a human machine by an extraterrestrial civilization, providing us the opportunity to make contact with life from another world.

The suggestion of a message on Pioneer 10 was brought to Dr. Carl Sagan mere months before launch—a staggeringly brief period in the timescale of the design and test of spacecraft. Sagan passed along the idea to NASA, and to his surprise, the suggestion was embraced and approved by every level of the hierarchy. At that, Sagan joined Professor Frank Drake of Cornell University and, Sagan’s then-wife, artist Linda Salzman Sagan, to craft this extraterrestrial message. How would this great undertaking be fulfilled? What would we say? What in our roughly five-thousand-year recorded history needs to be said to tell the universe who we are? And how would we say it?

Humans speak nearly seven thousand languages, some with multiple dialects. The countless other species on Earth communicate with innumerably more, nearly all of which we have, thus far, failed to understand. By extrapolation, it is presumable that an alien language is different than any language we have developed. Human languages are products of human minds, and thereby, can be understood by human minds, by means of human senses—sight, sound, touch. How could we begin to imagine an extraterrestrial language if we cannot imagine with what senses the beings communicate? They may not have vocal chords with which they produce sounds or ears with which they capture them. So we must rely on universally-understood concepts, and devise a communication method neither specific to location nor species nor world. Perhaps, the only similarity between our species is the universe in which we both live. Thus, the language we are most likely to share is the study of the universe itself: science. The result of this conclusion was the Pioneer Plaque.

The illustrations on the Pioneer Plaque

NASA

The illustrations on the Pioneer Plaque

The Pioneer Plaque is a physical, symbolic message affixed to the exterior of the Pioneer 10 spacecraft. At the core of this message is a fundamental concept that establishes a standard of distance and time, which, thereafter, is employed by the other components of the plaque. The design team postulated that hydrogen, being the most abundant element in the cosmos, would be one of the first elements to be studied by a civilization. With this in mind, they inscribed two hydrogen atoms at the top left of the plaque, each in a different energy state. When atoms of hydrogen change from one energy state to another—a process called the hyperfine transition—electromagnetic radiation is released. It is this wave that harbors the standard of measure used throughout the illustrations on the plaque. The wavelength (approximately 21 centimeters) serves as a spatial measurement, and the period (approximately .7 nanoseconds) serves as a measurement of time. The final detail of this schematic is a small tick between the atoms of hydrogen, assigning these values of distance and time to the binary number 1.

The most prominent figures on the plaque are those of two adult humans: a man and woman. The man bends his arm and displays an open palm—an international greeting, but one that, admittedly, may be meaningless to an extraterrestrial civilization. The woman hangs her arms by her sides and stands with her weight shifted rearward as to dispel any misunderstandings regarding a fixed body and limb position; we are mobile and flexible. Beside the illustrations of the humans is the binary number 8, inscribed between two ticks, indicating the height the woman. The civilization could then conclude that the woman is 8 units tall, the unit being the wavelength (21 centimeters) described by the hyperfine transition key; thus, the woman is 8 times 21 centimeters, or about 5.5 feet tall.

At the heart of the plaque is an array of lines and dashes—a cosmic address on the interstellar letter. In the center is our home star; the radial spokes signify the relative distances and directions to pulsars—rapidly rotating neutron stars that emit electromagnetic radiation at regular intervals. Accompanying each line is the period of the respective pulsar—once again, in binary. Not only does this map communicate position, but time as well—an epoch in the lifetime of the universe during which the message was sent. The rate of electromagnetic bursts from pulsars changes over time; thus, the period of the pulsars denoted on the plaque serves as a timestamp. It is presumed that a civilization that has developed radio astronomy will have the capability to comprehend the nature of pulsars. Given the information presented in the pulsar map, it is feasible that such a civilization could date back the message and triangulate our position. As further confirmation of our locale, our solar system’s planets (nine at the time) are depicted in the bottom margin of the plaque with their respective distances to the sun in binary. Supposedly, in the history of the Milky Way, only one star has ever fit the characteristics displayed on the plaque.

Pioneer Plaque

NASA

Pioneer Plaque
The Pioneer Plaque fixed to the Pioneer 10 spacecraft.

The last signal from the Pioneer 10 spacecraft was received on January 22, 2003; NASA reported that the power source had depleted. Although the spacecraft can no longer speak to us, it presses onward—it now speaks for us. As interstellar courier, it bears the accumulated voice of every human, transcribed in, perhaps, the only common language in all the cosmos. We are but cosmic toddlers just learning how to take our first steps into space, and just learning how to speak to the universe.

Since Pioneer 10 was directed neither to an exoplanet nor a star, contact is extremely unlikely. But if, by the merest happenstance, the spacecraft is intercepted by an alien species, there is at least a chance that the species can interpret our message. In all likelihood however, Pioneer 10 and its plaque will be lost in the immense tranquility of empty space. But in no case was our attempt for naught. Pioneer 10 remains more than just a ghost of a ship, and the plaque is more than a shout into the void. The message we sent to the universe still echoes in our ears. Born from such a mission—one that spans space, time, and perhaps, civilizations—is a new mindset, an otherworldly perspective.

From the vantage of a distant world, our sun will be just another star, and our planet hidden in the radiance of the stellar glow. On such a world—one so distant and different from our own—we have not the slightest indication of what life will be like, how it began, how it evolved. If beings were to emerge, we know not their anatomy nor biology nor psychology, their physical traits, their sensory capabilities, their intellectual sophistication, their disposition; more or less, we are blind to every aspect of their species. They could be different in every way—in ways we have yet to understand or could even imagine. We make numerous assumptions about what life is and what life is not—educated guesses based off a sample size of one. But if, in some form or another, advanced consciousness arises elsewhere in the cosmos, it is possible that those beings will wonder, as we did: What are the lights in the sky? Where did the planets come from? What else is out there? Who else is out there? They may compile a system of knowledge of the cosmos and the laws that govern it; we call this “science.” About this hypothetical species, we know but one thing: the science they develop—the natural laws they discover—if they were to do so, would be exactly the same as our own.

Although not every human conducts science, it is conducted for every human. Science speaks to all of us in a way nothing ever has. It sparks new ideas and alternate perspectives. It brings each of us together and all of us forward. It is, at the very least, an international language, because there is an implied assertion with every question: there is something we do not know; and with our missions, we learn together. We probe the unknown looking for answers, venturing to understand the universe as it is—not the way we want it or believe it to be. Every step of the way, we strive not to fit the universe to the limits of our minds, but stretch our minds to the limitlessness of the universe.  

Epilogue

For every great scientific discovery and technological advancement, there was a time before, when the universe was a little less known. The significance and brilliance of our technologies and the science that drives them is too often overlooked. We forget the time before—a time without cell phones and personal computers, automobiles and airplanes—during which we wondered what it would be like to communicate at the speed of light and fly around to the other side of the planet in a matter of hours. Right now, at this time, we wonder what it would be like to find life elsewhere in the cosmos and to make first contact. This is the time before that great discovery, and there will be a time after. Maybe in the near future, or maybe a more distant one, it will be commonplace to carry on conversations with extraterrestrials; and again, we will forget how, right now, we are ceaselessly wondering, in endless search for an answer.


Sources:

A Message from Earth, by Carl Sagan, Linda Salzman Sagan, and Frank Drake

The Cosmic Connection, by Carl Sagan

PIONEER 10 SPACECRAFT SENDS LAST SIGNAL, by Michael Mewhinney

 
See other posts from January 2016

 

Or read more blog entries about: history, Pioneer 10 and 11

Comments:

rob: 01/20/2016 11:44 CST

In addition to the finders of the plaque being able to deduce the females figure as being 8 time 21 centimeters tall, there is a schematic of the Pioneer space craft behind the human figures that the finders can use to see if the proportions or even the 21 centimeter wavelength is correct

ToSeek: 01/20/2016 05:35 CST

How are they going to find us now that Pluto is no longer a planet?

Julia: 01/20/2016 11:33 CST

Whether we consider Pluto a planet is probably not a concern for such an advanced species who would stumble upon our little message. My greatest "concern" ( for lack of a better word ) is what type of folks would actually find our plaque, and what their motives would be in wanting to visit us. While I absolutely wish that only really nice explorers would stop by and say "hello", it could just as likely be someone or thing altogether different. Either way, planet Earth is communicating, and someday, someone will communicate back.

Karen: 01/21/2016 05:18 CST

The Pioneer Plaque is rather poorly designed compared to many later "universal language" messages that have been created over the years. I remember when I tried to work out the meanings myself and was very frustrated when I learned how they were encoding things. Nowadays there's some really clever universal language projects. My two favorites are: 1) those like Lincos that use logic statements and mathematics to build up an increasingly complex list of facts, culminating in a whole dictionary and logic-based grammar; and 2) algorithmic approaches like CosmicOS wherein the first part shows an alien species how to program a virtual machine (in a manner similar to Lincos) which can then run the second part, so any sort of complex, even interactive environment can be provided to the recipient.

Daniel: 01/21/2016 10:28 CST

But, Karen, would all of that fit in a plack? It can only be so big, the plaque. Weight concerns and such during ascent.

Dan_B: 01/21/2016 12:20 CST

How sad that the plaque contains such serious errors. Some day in the near future benevolent aliens may find Pioneer 10 and decide that its builders seem to be really smart beings and wish to come share all their secrets of health and long life. Alas a debate will then ensue among them. The first decrypter (call him Bob) will point to our solar system and say "There it is! Nine planets! Let's go help them!" The wiser ones though, who have a very deep understanding of the universal definition of a planet, will say, "But wait the solar system in this diagram shows NINE planets. The one you are pointing to Bob clearly only has seven planets. Our investigations show that the very small icy outer body with the large companion satellite hasn't 'cleared its neighborhood.' In fact the very large fifth body comprising most of the non-solar mass of the system hasn't cleared IT'S neighborhood either! Therefore there are only seven planets. No, this cannot be the solar system where this ingenious spacecraft with its clever plaque originated. Let us move on with our wonderful gifts of wisdom and knowledge until we find the correct system where the inhabitants obviously understand the universal definition of a planet!" And the benevolent aliens will pass us by, all because Sagan, his wife Linda, Professor Drake, and the silly people of the 1970s did not understand what a planet is.

Karen: 01/21/2016 02:54 CST

Daniel: plaques aren't the only one way one can encode informtion, of course ;) The voyager spacecraft, for example, contained golden records with information on how to play them. We have much better ways to store data over long periods of time now, although even if it was just another golden record, but with digital encoding rather than analog, we could store a vast amount of information there within.

Leave a Comment:

You must be logged in to submit a comment. Log in now.
Facebook Twitter Email RSS AddThis

Blog Search

Essential Advocacy

Our Advocacy Program 
provides each Society member 
a voice in the process.



Funding is critical. The more 
we have, the more effective 
we can be, translating into more 
missions, more science, 
and more exploration.

Donate

Featured Images

Phobos sample return mission
BEAM expansion progress
THAICOM 8 drone ship landing
BEAM on Canadarm
More Images

Featured Video

The Planetary Post - A Visit To JPL

Watch Now

Space in Images

Pretty pictures and
awe-inspiring science.

See More

Join the New Millennium Committee

Let’s invent the future together!

Become a Member

Connect With Us

Facebook, Twitter, YouTube and more…
Continue the conversation with our online community!