Help Shape the Future of Space Exploration

Join The Planetary Society Now  arrow.png

Join our eNewsletter for updates & action alerts

    Please leave this field empty
Blogs

Phil Stooke

Finding the Surveyor retro-rockets on the Moon

Posted by Phil Stooke

15-09-2015 13:02 CDT

Topics: NASA lunar missions before 2005, pretty pictures, pics of spacecraft in space, amateur image processing, the Moon

The Apollo landings on the Moon followed a series of robotic landings by NASA’s Surveyor spacecraft. Five of the seven Surveyors landed successfully between 1966 and 1968. Most of the Surveyors were sent to the three general regions where astronauts might land on the first few missions: close to the equator in the western, central, and eastern maria. Surveyor 1 was directed to the region in Oceanus Procellarum that allowed the simplest descent profile—a vertical descent from the approach trajectory. It landed safely, a few months after the Soviet Union had achieved the first lunar landing with Luna 9. Then Surveyor 2 was sent to Sinus Medii, the central landing region, but it failed during flight and crashed. Surveyor 3 landed safely in the western region, in a part of Oceanus Procellarum now referred to as Mare Insularum, the Sea of Islands. Surveyor 4 went back to Sinus Medii but failed during its final approach. Surveyor 5 landed safely in Mare Tranquillitatis, a bit off course but not too far from the eventual Apollo 11 landing site. Surveyor 6 finally achieved the goal of a landing in Sinus Medii, and with all three Apollo regions now certified safe, Surveyor 7 landed in the southern highlands near the crater Tycho on a purely scientific mission.

As the Surveyors reached the Moon, they were braked to near-zero velocity by a solid fuel retro-rocket mounted underneath the lander. The retro-rocket was ejected near the surface and fell to the ground, as three small rockets called verniers ignited to bring the lander safely to the ground. The process was not always uneventful. Surveyor 3’s verniers failed to cut off after landing and the vehicle bounced twice down the gentle slope of an old crater before ground controllers could turn them off. Surveyor 4 probably failed when one or more of its verniers failed to ignite.

Apollo 12 landing area

NASA / JPL-Caltech / ASU / Phil Stooke

Apollo 12 landing area

This image shows the Apollo 12 landing area in a Lunar Reconnaissance Orbiter (LRO) image taken with the sun almost overhead. This rather unfamiliar lighting means we can’t see any shadows, so craters and rocks don’t show up well. But several dark spots are very obvious. One is the Apollo 12 Lunar Module whose base is still on the Moon. Another is Surveyor 3 itself. Surveyor was an open framework structure, and the spacecraft components cast shadows, which we can see through the gaps in the frame, so it looks dark. Disturbed soil looks dark as well, so astronaut tracks can be seen on the surface. Some bright markings reveal the reflective surfaces of parts of the ALSEP (Apollo Lunar Surface Experiment Package), equipment set out on the surface by the astronauts. But there’s an unexplained dark spot at upper right in the image. Could it be the Surveyor retro-rocket?

The Surveyor retro-rocket?

NASA / JPL-Caltech / ASU / Phil Stooke

The Surveyor retro-rocket?

The panels above show that it probably is the retro-rocket. At left, a Lunar Orbiter image shows the area of that spot before Surveyor 3 landed. Next to it is an LRO image showing a dark spot that was not there in the earlier image. The light is coming from a different direction, but at a similar angle. Next, the high sun image shows the dark spot without shadows, and an enlargement shows a few other markings near it. It looks as if the rocket casing might have bounced or rolled, or perhaps the nozzle was thrown off it and made the smaller marks.

Surveyor spacecraft (with added labels to show the components)

NASA / JPL-Caltech / Phil Stooke

Surveyor spacecraft (with added labels to show the components)

The image above shows a Surveyor spacecraft with the rocket casing in place. The casing is about 1 m (3 feet) across. Below is the best view of this object, taken when LRO dropped to a very low orbit for a short time. The dark spot is in a distinct crater, just a couple of meters across.

LRO's best view of the possible Surveyor retro-rocket

NASA / JPL-Caltech / ASU

LRO's best view of the possible Surveyor retro-rocket

I noticed this spot in 2009 and presented it with other observations at the Lunar and Planetary Science Conference (LPSC) in 2010. But I always wondered if other retro-rockets might be found. Now I have what I think are good candidates for Surveyors 5 and 6. In both cases the high sun images help to locate the retro-rocket. The dark disturbed surface is easy to spot when there are no shadows. I’m not yet sure about Surveyor 1, and I have no idea about Surveyor 7 because the sun is never overhead at its latitude.

Surveyor 5 landing site and possible retro-rocket

NASA / JPL-Caltech / ASU / Phil Stooke

Surveyor 5 landing site and possible retro-rocket
Surveyor 6 landing site and possible retro-rocket

NASA / JPL-Caltech / ASU / Phil Stooke

Surveyor 6 landing site and possible retro-rocket

Both the Surveyor 5 and 6 landing sites have suggestions of a linear marking where a roll or bounce might have left a mark on the surface. These are quite good candidates for retro-rockets, but there is still some uncertainty. All the same, this shows that there are still things to look for on the Moon. In my mind the greatest find would be Luna 9, the Soviet Union’s first successful lander. But its location is quite uncertain and it would take a great deal of both luck and skill to find it.

 
See other posts from September 2015

 

Or read more blog entries about: NASA lunar missions before 2005, pretty pictures, pics of spacecraft in space, amateur image processing, the Moon

Comments:

GSS: 09/15/2015 04:58 CDT

Awesome work! Visually exhausting no doubt. I love the feeling of space archaeology that this type of work elicits. One hopes that with the digitization opportunities for the 1960s (and beyond) data, more discoveries like this may be possible. Surveyor is one of my most favorite spacecraft and I often consider Apollo 12 as the first extraterrestrial archaeological expedition. http://www.aircraftresourcecenter.com/Gal10/9301-9400/gal9388-Surveyor-Symmonds/00.shtm

BillinGlendale: 09/15/2015 05:45 CDT

Great effort. Surveyor was a big step forward in reliability in the early Space Age. Is there a consistent offset of the retro relative to the approach trajectory?

karle: 09/17/2015 05:00 CDT

Phil, awesome detective work as usual! to commenter GSS (nice work on your model!) also see the NASM 1/5 model here: http://airandspace.si.edu/explore-and-learn/multimedia/detail.cfm?id=A19690236000&file=A19690236000PS2011-02453.jpg&name=Model%2C%20Lunar%20Lander%2C%20Surveyor%2C%201%2F5%20Scale

Bob Ware: 09/26/2015 02:45 CDT

At some future date a museum curator is going to like what you did and go after these artifacts. Thank you for your effort! It was worth it to you I'm sure. It's good to see this effort and finally as a bonus, getting the landing hoaxers to finally go away! Anything they come up with after this type of work will clearly be fantasy to us though more reality in their own world.

Ian Regan: 09/29/2015 04:53 CDT

I have an exciting addendum to Phil's Surveyor 3 retro-rocket discovery; last night, I came upon the candidate crater formed by the retro-rocket impact in the Apollo 12 descent film: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NlgGveDiqW4 It first appears at 3:24, is best seen around the 3:39 mark, and goes out of frame at 3:51. A frame culled from the 16-mm film (shot out of LMP Alan Bean's window), is shown below alongside a crop of the highest resolution LRO frame: http://s16.postimg.org/d6tgvjl8z/Surveyor_3_Retro_rocket_crater.png My thanks to Phil for confirming what I think is a rather interesting find: a man-made crater within walking distant of one of the Apollo landing sites!

Leave a Comment:

You must be logged in to submit a comment. Log in now.
Facebook Twitter Email RSS AddThis

Blog Search

Essential Advocacy

Our Advocacy Program provides each Society member a voice in the process.

Funding is critical. The more we have, the more effective we can be, translating into more missions, more science, and more exploration.

Donate

Featured Images

NGC 4100
The Flaming Star Nebula (IC 405)
LDN 604 and GGD 30
Schiaparelli backshell and parachute landing location from HiRISE in color
More Images

Featured Video

The Planetary Post - Carl Sagan's Pale Blue Dot

Watch Now

Space in Images

Pretty pictures and
awe-inspiring science.

See More

Join The Planetary Society

Let’s explore the cosmos together!

Become a Member

Connect With Us

Facebook, Twitter, YouTube and more…
Continue the conversation with our online community!