Help Shape the Future of Space Exploration

Join The Planetary Society Now  arrow.png

Join our eNewsletter for updates & action alerts

    Please leave this field empty

Headshot of Emily Lakdawalla

Days before its crash, LADEE saw zodiacal light above the lunar horizon

Posted by Emily Lakdawalla

23-04-2014 12:55 CDT

Topics: pretty pictures, mission status, the Sun, LADEE, the Moon

LADEE is no more. It crashed into the surface of the Moon on April 17, as any low-altitude lunar mission running low on fuel inevitably will. As a mission that studied the lunar exosphere in situ, the closer they were able to fly to the surface, the more atmospheric molecules and particles they were able to taste. According to project scientist Rick Elphic, the final days of the mission have turned out to be very productive, as hoped.

LADEE ran its science instruments almost non-stop right up to impact the evening of April 17, 2014, in an effort to gather as much low-altitude data as possible. Further study of the returned data will reveal what the instruments saw at these amazingly low orbits, just a few kilometers above the surface. Early results suggest that LADEE was low enough to see some new things, including increased dust density and possibly new atmospheric species. In an incredible race with time, LADEE’s Real Time Operations team queued and downloaded all science files just minutes prior to LADEE's impact.

So, before I say anything more: congratulations to the LADEE team for a job well done, and I'm looking forward to all the science results yet to come!

But they have already released one really cool set of data, one that didn't come from the science instruments, but rather from an engineering camera. LADEE's star tracker instrument (used for spacecraft navigation, to help the spacecraft autonomously determine its orientation in space) was, like many star trackers these days, a camera. And they used it in a really cool way, to watch the Sun rise over the lunar horizon during one of their really low-altitude orbits. Here's the animation, which I've looped so you can watch it over and over.

Zodiacal light at the Moon from LADEE


Zodiacal light at the Moon from LADEE
The LADEE Moon orbiter took this series of images of the Sun rising above the lunar horizon on April 12, 2014, just five days before LADEE's orbit decayed to the point where it crashed into the lunar surface. The series begins with LADEE viewing the lunar horizon ahead, a few minutes before orbital sunrise. At this position, there is already a glow of zodiacal light in the sky above the completely dark surface of the Moon, though the Sun is many degrees below the horizon. LADEE’s orbital motion makes the stars appear to move to the left. The same motion brings the Sun closer to the horizon ahead and the glow gets brighter. In fact, the glow becomes so bright, parts of the image are saturated. Finally, sunrise fully saturates the camera image.

They took this series of images in order to reproduce an observation made by Gene Cernan 40 years ago, as Elphic explained in an earlier blog post:

Taking images is an unusual task for a star tracker, since its main purpose is to determine where in space it is looking, like a navigator, so the spacecraft can know its attitude relative to sun, moon and Earth. It so happens that the star trackers are able to compress and save images every eight seconds. If those images contain not just stars, but the dark limb of the unlit moon, an interesting possibility presents itself: what if we could reproduce the famous view that Apollo astronaut Eugene Cernan sketched more than 40 years ago? What if we could see a horizon glow just before orbital sunrise? Might we see levitated dust, illuminated by sunshine while LADEE is in the dark shadow of the moon?

Here's the oft-reproduced page of Cernan's observations. What the Apollo astronauts saw in the lunar sunrise was attributed to three sources. Of these, one was external to the Moon -- zodiacal light (annotated in red) -- and two were hypothesized to result from dust levitated above the lunar surface -- lunar horizon glow and crepuscular rays (annotated in blue and green).

Gene Cernan's sketch of the sunrise as seen from lunar orbit


Gene Cernan's sketch of the sunrise as seen from lunar orbit
This is a sketch of the lunar sunrise seen from orbit by Apollo 17 astronaut Eugene Cernan. Highlights in the right image show the sources of the scattered light.

The LADEE team really, really wanted to see that lunar horizon glow and crepuscular rays, indicating that they were actually able to see phenomena related to the lunar exosphere, the subject of their science mission, in photographs. Unfortunately, the star tracker images don't seem to contain either. But they do show zodiacal light. Elphic explains:

The shape of this glow is familiar; we've seen it before. The images reveal a phenomenon that even we can see during a dark, clear night after sunset here on Earth – the zodiacal light. What is zodiacal light? It is the scattered sunlight from billions upon billions of dust grains, not at the Moon, but in the innermost reaches of the solar system. The origin of this dust appears to be comets, which shed gas and dust in their orbital progress around the sun. The lenticular shape of the zodiacal light, seen in the LADEE star tracker images, results from the tendency of the dust to be more concentrated near the orbital plane of the planets.

Unlike Eugene Cernan's sketches from his vantage point in the Apollo 17 command module, America, LADEE saw no rays or other strange features - just good old zodiacal light, plus possibly the outer fringes of the sun's corona. LADEE took several sequences of these orbital sunrise images, and for now, nothing has shown up that clearly is lunar in origin. In the coming weeks and months, we'll carefully analyze these images, and perhaps something related to levitated lunar dust will emerge.

But it sure looks like sunrise is just as impressive from LADEE's vantage point as it is to us on Earth.

Indeed it does. And it took delicate work to obtain the beautiful sequence of photographs from a spacecraft skimming within a few thousand meters of the surface of another world. Again, I congratulate the LADEE team on their fine mission.

See other posts from April 2014


Or read more blog entries about: pretty pictures, mission status, the Sun, LADEE, the Moon


Edgar J. Kaiser: 04/23/2014 01:11 CDT

Before the crash the publically announced estimate for the crash date was April 21st. So I am wondering if the crash on April 17th may have been a surprise to the project team? Any unknown mountain peak that was in the way? Or - did it really crash on April 17th or did it just loose the communication system? There is probably no means to verify that.

Jonathan Ursin: 04/24/2014 12:27 CDT

Edgar, I was confused as well. April 17th was nowhere near my 'take the plunge' guess. I found this post on Ladees official site. I think there was uncertainty in how such a low orbit would influence the satellite.

Adolf Schaller: 04/30/2014 06:35 CDT

In the caption to the gif sequence it states that the motion of the spacecraft makes the stars appear to move to the left. On the contrary, the stars appear to be moving directly upward, slightly angled to the right.

Adolf Schaller: 04/30/2014 07:31 CDT

On the issue of the interpretation of 'crepuscular rays' in Apollo 17 commander Gene Cernan's sketches and notes, it is curious that they were not reported to exhibit substantial change or motion, as one would expect with the rapidly changing geometry between the position of an orbiting spacecraft with respect to surface topographic features and the light source beneath the horizon. I am not alone in having concluded long ago (circa late 1970's) that what Cernan and other Apollo astronauts saw in the 'radial streamers' before orbital sunrise and after sunset were in fact features of the outer corona of the Sun. It's too bad the LADEE team were not able to confirm a hypothesis that's been adhered to by some for 40+ years, but its good to know that science rejects and corrects as well as adds. A negative result shouldn't be viewed as a disappointment, but a liberation.

Leave a Comment:

You must be logged in to submit a comment. Log in now.
Facebook Twitter Email RSS AddThis

Blog Search

LightSail - Flight by Light

Support LightSail!

In 2016, The Planetary Society’s LightSail program will take the technology a step further.

I want to help!

Featured Images

Philae's landing site in 3D

Hayabusa-2 spacecraft
Curiosity in-situ science targets at Confidence Hills, sols 758-771
The Confidence Hills work area at the edge of Pahrump Hills outcrop, Curiosity sol 777
More Images

Featured Video

View Larger »

Space in Images

Pretty pictures and
awe-inspiring science.

See More

Join the New Millennium Committee

Let’s invent the future together!

Become a Member

Connect With Us

Facebook! Twitter! Google+ and more…
Continue the conversation with our online community!