Help Shape the Future of Space Exploration

Join The Planetary Society Now  arrow.png

Join our eNewsletter for updates & action alerts

    Please leave this field empty

Headshot of Emily Lakdawalla

Yes, it was once a Martian lake: Curiosity has been sent to the right place

Posted by Emily Lakdawalla

12-03-2013 17:36 CDT

Topics: mission status, pretty pictures, explaining science, Mars, Curiosity (Mars Science Laboratory), geology, hydrology, mineralogy and petrology

The news from the Curiosity mission today is this: Curiosity has found, at the site called John Klein, a rock that contains evidence for a past environment that would have been suitable for Earth-like microorganisms. The rock contains fairly abundant clay minerals, which are usually formed by the alteration of other minerals in the presence of water. Unlike the hypersaline or strongly acid only rarely watery environments explored by Spirit and Opportunity, the environment chronicled by the rocks at John Klein looks a lot more pleasant, with neutral or slightly alkaline pH, maybe slightly salty.

Taken together, the mineralogical and geomorphological observations suggest that the rover's wheels are sitting on an ancient Martian lakebed, an environment that has been hypothesized to have existed on Mars but which has never before been explored in situ.

Curiosity MAHLI self-portrait, sol 177

NASA / JPL / MSSS / Ed Truthan

Curiosity MAHLI self-portrait, sol 177
A total of 64 frames shot by the MAHLI on the end of Curiosity's robotic arm were required for this large mosaic. On sol 177 (February 3, 2013), the rover was sitting at the "John Klein" site, preparing to drill for the first time. Zoom in at lower left and you can see two gray marks on the ground where Curiosity tested out the drill in percussion mode on sols 174 and 176.

The rock also contains both oxidized and reduced forms of the same elements, meaning (said John Grotzinger at today's press briefing) that there are chemical gradients that Earth-like life could potentially exploit as an energy source. I won't go into detail on the chemistry of the findings because I am hoping that I will get a lot more detail, more thoroughly explained, with more discussion of the relative certainty of the findings, at next week's Lunar and Planetary Science Conference. But here are the pretty rainbow Chemin X-ray diffraction spectra they released today.

X-ray diffraction spectra for Chemin analyses of samples from the

NASA / JPL / Ames

X-ray diffraction spectra for Chemin analyses of samples from the "Rocknest" and "John Klein" sites
This side-by-side comparison shows the X-ray diffraction patterns of two different samples collected from the Martian surface by NASA's Curiosity rover. These images, made from data obtained by Curiosity's Chemistry and Mineralogy instrument (CheMin), show the patterns obtained from a drift of windblown dust and sand called "Rocknest" and from a powdered rock sample drilled from the "John Klein" bedrock. The presence of abundant clay minerals (labeled "phyllosilicate") in the John Klein drill powder and the lack of abundant salt suggest a fresh water environment.

This isn't "mission success" for Curiosity yet, but it's an important step in the right direction. The overarching scientific goal of the Curiosity mission is "to explore and quantitatively assess a local region on Mars' surface as a potential habitat for life, past or present." Note that the way this is written, Curiosity could be declared a successful mission whether or not they ever found such a habitable environment; it's the exploration and assessment that's important. At John Klein that exploration has begun, but there's much more to do.

Although today's briefing featured the Curiosity mission, this announcement has ramifications far beyond Curiosity, and here's why. It wasn't Curiosity data that led the rover team to a decision to explore at John Klein. The decision to drive to this particular spot was made based upon the enormous data sets acquired by all of Curiosity's predecessors. The real significance of this moment is that it ground-truths some of the conclusions drawn from orbital data sets.

Two orbiting missions in particular deserve credit for the discovery of this ancient habitable environment: ESA's Mars Express and NASA's Mars Reconnaissance Orbiter. Both of them carry imaging spectrometers (OMEGA on Mars Express, CRISM on Mars Reconnaissance Orbiter) that are capable of mapping variations in surface composition with high resolution, unlike their coarser-resolution predecessors TES on Mars Global Surveyor and THEMIS on Mars Odyssey.

But resolution wasn't the only difference among these spectrometers. OMEGA and CRISM see a different part of the electromagnetic spectrum than TES did and THEMIS still does. TES and THEMIS operate in the thermal infrared, where variations in the composition of silicate minerals express themselves as wiggles in spectra. OMEGA and CRISM operate in shorter, near-infrared wavelengths, which gives them the ability to detect water bound into crystals, and to find other minerals like sulfates and carbonates. Clay minerals mapped out in tiny exposures by OMEGA and CRISM became the important target for the future Mars Science Laboratory mission, and Gale crater was selected in part because of the conclusion that clay minerals were present there.

CRISM map of Gale crater, with Curiosity landing site marked

NASA / JPL / JHUAPL / Ralph Milliken

CRISM map of Gale crater, with Curiosity landing site marked
A colorful map of the mineralogy at Gale Crater. Greens are phyllosilicates (clays), blue and magenta are sulfates, red is olivine, and orange is mixed sulfates and clays. The landing site is marked by a yellow cross at the top center of this image.

There is one fly in the ointment. Neither of the two orbiters saw a strong signal from clay minerals at the specific spot where Curiosity is sitting. Look at that map and you'll see there's no strong spectral signal of any kind from the John Klein unit. It's got a scattering of green and blue pixels, which would imply the presence of clays and sulfates, which is consistent with today's results; but the signal is not strong. Not in near-infrared wavelengths, anyway. But this unit was a bright beacon in Mars Odyssey THEMIS maps of Gale. I'm looking forward to hearing the Curiosity team reconcile all these data sets. And I'm looking forward to going to the mountain to see why the clay- and sulfate-mineral signatures are so much stronger there.

Blink comparison of daytime and nighttime infrared views of Gale crater

NASA / JPL / ASU / Emily Lakdawalla

Blink comparison of daytime and nighttime infrared views of Gale crater
The Curiosity landing site is marked with a yellow square, just to the south of a deposit of material that is bright at night and dark during the day. This material is referred to as the "high thermal inertia unit" by the Curiosity science team.

Going back to Curiosity's overarching goal, the rover has now succeeded in exploring and quantitatively assessing a local region on Mars' surface as a potential habitat for life. Obviously, though, there's a lot of work yet to be done. Curiosity's next steps will include further study of the John Klein site with at least one more drilled sample in order to understand the compositional variety of the site, and to understand what kind of time might be represented by this rock -- how long did this environment last? Was it intermittent, recurrent, or continuously present for some lengthy period of time?

Curiosity's team members would also like to understand how the lakebed sediments found at John Klein relate to the huge stack of sediments that form Gale crater's central mound. John Klein could potentially have formed in just about any period of Mars' sedimentary history. The John Klein rocks could have formed at the toe of an alluvial fan that comes down from Gale's rim, which would imply that the rock is young relative to most of Mars' geologic activity. That's how it's been mapped in Ryan Anderson and Jim Bell's Gale crater survey. Or they could actually represent the very lowest levels of the sedimentary stack that includes Gale's central mountain, in which case they would be quite old. It's not inconceivable that they represent some intermediate age, some intermittent pool of water that formed for a time on the floor of the crater after the central mound formed but before the alluvial fan formed. Figuring out the stratigraphic relationship between John Klein and the mountain is going to be a major motivation of the next several months of Curiosity's mission.

I saw this joke earlier today on Twitter, but it actually kind of sums up the significance of today's findings: Curiosity has been sent to the right place. It has an instrument suite that was particularly designed to study the kinds of rocks it has found. Hooray for the Mars program! Hooray for the "squiggly lines" of infrared spectra!

Back on Mars, the rover is still not doing science operations; they are continuing to work on understanding and fixing the problem with the Side A computer. While I am sure that none of the Curiosity team would have wished for this forced break in science operations, I hope it'll have a good effect in that the couple of weeks of no new data right before the Lunar and Planetary Science Conference might mean that the science team has had a chance to actually think about their data before they speak about it.

See other posts from March 2013


Or read more blog entries about: mission status, pretty pictures, explaining science, Mars, Curiosity (Mars Science Laboratory), geology, hydrology, mineralogy and petrology


Mike Kerna: 03/12/2013 06:08 CDT

Very exciting. I wish the 2020 mission wasn't so far away.

Tam: 03/12/2013 07:48 CDT

thak you, thank youj, thank you & huge thanks & hugs to Curosity. I've been waiting for this day since 1957. Now just 2 mofe factors to go before I croak-which I hope isn't real soon anyway-(1) definite proof of micro-organisms, or anyother life forms, and(2) E.T. calls home.

imrekarika: 03/12/2013 10:11 CDT

*75*Let it be imagined that a lot are a direction around our Earth towards it universe services leak continuously.The basis wavelength of all universes differs from the other world's,because of this the different universes cannot be seen simultaneously, some in a normal case the from among a lot,I may look at only a television's brodcast simultaneously. With the bills of the wavelengths other television broadcasts will be visible. So,if my universes passage the mass of my vehicle with an other wavelength onto a vibration I succeed to switch over,then it from this system a new other one jumps over into a system,that ship it his passengers together from here an other one is transferred for universe the traffic one his service. That ship can come back so from that world only,if the vibrations of the mass of the vehicle from the new wavelength we are able to place it back onto our old wavelength. This universe-ship was at a standstill in both worlds,one of the universes pushed it out from himself.

John Burch: 03/13/2013 11:27 CDT

2020 is not that long away. In fact its just about right for Curiosity's findings over the next 2 years to define the instrument payload of the 2020 rover. Great news and many, many congratulations to everybody involved

stars2heaven: 03/13/2013 07:31 CDT

I have seen a lot of people in lots of different forums discussing these latest findings from Curiosity. It seems that there are a huge number of people who don't quite understand their significance or importance. Generally comments are along the lines of, "Haven't scientists been saying this for years?" or, "So what's new?" So how does this new information fit in to what we already knew about Mars?

Doug Currie: 03/16/2013 12:41 CDT

That is very encouraging that the clays and sulfates indicate there was a fairly neutral level of ph in the water at the present site of Curiousity. However the Sam facility anyway can detect organic chemicals so has it detected methane or any more advanced organic chemicals in the drill samples in which the sulfates and clays were detected. This might give more definite evidence that ancient microbes could have been in the clays or sulfates or their associated water.

Emily Lakdawalla: 03/25/2013 05:50 CDT

stars2heaven: The kind of environment represented by the mudstone under Curiosity's wheels is one that we've been looking for on Mars since the beginning of the space age, but have never found yet. Finally we have proof that yes, there were once places on Mars that would've been friendly to all kinds of microbial life, not just ones that were hyper-adapted to horribly acid or oxidizing or super-hot or super-cold environments. It's the kind of place where you might imagine a primordial soup to exist and would be benign to organic chemistry.

Leave a Comment:

You must be logged in to submit a comment. Log in now.
Facebook Twitter Email RSS AddThis

Blog Search

Planetary Defense

An asteroid or comet headed for Earth is the only large-scale natural disaster we can prevent. Working together to fund our Shoemaker NEO Grants for astronomers, we can help save the world.


Featured Images

LightSail 2 and Prox-1
Bill Nye at LightSail 2 pre-ship review
LightSail 2 pre-ship review team photo
Swirling maelstrom
More Images

Featured Video

Class 9: Saturn, Uranus, and Neptune

Watch Now

Space in Images

Pretty pictures and
awe-inspiring science.

See More

Join The Planetary Society

Let’s explore the cosmos together!

Become a Member

Connect With Us

Facebook, Twitter, YouTube and more…
Continue the conversation with our online community!