Help Shape the Future of Space Exploration

Join The Planetary Society Now  arrow.png

Join our eNewsletter for updates & action alerts

    Please leave this field empty

Headshot of Emily Lakdawalla

Carl Sagan: "If membership is restricted to men, the loss will be ours."

Posted by Emily Lakdawalla

13-11-2012 1:06 CST

Topics: personal stories

When Casey invited me to participate in last Friday's "Sagan Slam," I wasn't sure what I would read. I consider Carl Sagan to be among many people who inspired me to want to tell the world about science and space, but am a little uncomfortable with what seems to me to be a tendency to ascribe sainthood to him (or to any other human).

While I was reading my news feeds Friday morning it occurred to me to ask the question: what were his opinions on feminism? And my searches led to this letter, on the terrific "Letters of Note" website. Sagan wrote the letter, in 1981, to convince the leadership of the hitherto all-male Explorers Club to begin admitting women to its ranks. I read the whole thing at the Slam; follow the link to read it for yourself. Here is an excerpt:

When our organization was formed in 1905, men were preventing women from voting and from pursuing many occupations for which they are clearly suited. In the popular mind, exploration was not what women did. Even so, women had played a significant but unheralded role in the history of exploration....

Today women are making extraordinary contributions in areas of fundamental interest to our organization. There are several women astronauts. The earliest footprints -- 3.6 million years old -- made by a member of the human family have been found in a volcanic ash flow in Tanzania by Mary Leakey. Trailblazing studies of the behavior of primates in the wild have been performed by dozens of young women, each spending years with a different primate species. Jane Goodall's studies of the chimpanzee are the best known of the investigations which illuminate human origins. The undersea depth record is held by Sylvia Earle. The solar wind was first measured in situ by Marcia Neugebauer, using the Mariner 2 spacecraft. The first active volcanos beyond the Earth were discovered on the Jovian moon Io by Linda Morabito, using the Voyager 1 spacecraft. These examples of modern exploration and discovery could be multiplied a hundredfold. They are of true historical significance. If membership in The Explorers Club is restricted to men, the loss will be ours; we will only be depriving ourselves....

(The Explorers Club did, in fact, begin admitting women later that year.)

Earlier in the evening, at our Sagan Day event, I had spoken about how Carl Sagan was one of many television scientists whose nightly appearance in my living room educated me and opened my eyes to Nature's wonders and the thrill of discovering them. Him and David Attenborough, Philip Morrison, James Burke, Jacques Cousteau, and Don Herbert. All men. Which was never a particular problem for me, except that I felt that I needed to be "one of the boys" in order to participate in these pursuits. I was even taught, in college, that the talents that I possess that allow me to work alongside the men in scientific research were "masculine" ones.

Thanks to letters like this one -- there must be many other examples, written by many other leaders, since the 1960s -- there are, now, lots more women in science, and you can see that you don't have to renounce the feminine in order to work in a technological field. Girls can do good science -- even while wearing a skirt! (Heck, guys could do good science while wearing a skirt, if they were so inclined.)

-- However, and this is a big "however," if I were a kid today listing inspiring science TV hosts, I'd still only be naming men, I think. The only non-male sci/tech show cohost who immediately comes to mind is Kari Byron. I don't watch a lot of TV though, so I'm probably missing some. If you know of any others, please put them in the comments!

If you missed our Sagan Day event, or were frustrated by the failure of the webcast, here's a video.

See other posts from November 2012


Or read more blog entries about: personal stories


jelfving: 11/13/2012 05:43 CST

It seems to me - not being a very avid TV-watcher - that three scientific shows in, respectively, Finland, Sweden and Denmark are all hosted by women.

Ljubo: 11/13/2012 09:13 CST

Dr Helen Czerski often appears in/hosts BBC documentaries.

Carlos: 11/13/2012 12:39 CST

People that love Carl Sagan is only because he shared his love for science and astronomy with anyone who wanted to listen him. If his legacy isn't renewed, it's normal that people remember him. Really what matters are his ideas, not his personality. Cosmos is a beautiful documentary, but now is a bit outdated, the astronomy and science are in constant evolution, and his ideas too. I have nothing to do with science or astronomy, but if someone knew to share passion for astronomy, that was Carl. Forgive my English.

Logan5: 11/13/2012 07:09 CST

These days, people go to television to watch things blow up and listen to a leading actor speculate about science - not that their's anything wrong with that. However, if you want to learn something go to a Google Hangouts hosted by women like Emily Lakdawalla and Pamala Gay :-) I would love to see a US science show hosted by a woman. I hope that day will be soon

Logan5: 11/13/2012 07:13 CST

I noticed I typed "their's" instead of "there's". Sorry.

PrestonP: 11/17/2012 07:00 CST

I think that letter is pretty much a good representation of science in 1981. However today there are just as many opportunities for women as men. Gender really doesn't play any role. Last I checked the year is 2012.... As for women on TV. The Universe series has several women they show each season. How The Universe Works series has different speakers depending on which season and what medium you are using (DVD or broadcast or Netflix). PBS has shown women in several of their NOVA episodes dealing with astronomy and space. The podcast Stardate from McDonald observatory is hosted by a woman and has been since I can remember. And a previous poster mentioned Astronomy Cast with Pamela Gay. So I guess it really depends on what you are watching. If you are not seeing any women, you are probably not looking.

Leave a Comment:

You must be logged in to submit a comment. Log in now.
Facebook Twitter Email RSS AddThis

Blog Search

Planetary Defense

An asteroid or comet headed for Earth is the only large-scale natural disaster we can prevent. Working together to fund our Shoemaker NEO Grants for astronomers, we can help save the world.


Featured Images

Opportunity panorama at Rocheport
Ice Flows and Dunes in Mars' Northern Polar Region
The TRAPPIST-1 system: Where might liquid water exist?
The TRAPPIST-1 system
More Images

Featured Video

Intro Astronomy 2017. Class 5: Venus & Mars

Watch Now

Space in Images

Pretty pictures and
awe-inspiring science.

See More

Join The Planetary Society

Let’s explore the cosmos together!

Become a Member

Connect With Us

Facebook, Twitter, YouTube and more…
Continue the conversation with our online community!