Help Shape the Future of Space Exploration

Join The Planetary Society Now Join Now!

Join our eNewsletter for updates & action alerts

   Please leave this field empty
Blogs

See other posts from May 2010

Headshot of Emily Lakdawalla

Saturn's hexagon recreated in the laboratory

Posted by Emily Lakdawalla

2010/05/04 12:32 CDT

Topics:

A lot of readers have expressed interest in the origin of Saturn's north polar hexagon. The hexagon is a long-lived pattern in the clouds surrounding Saturn's north pole, which has been observed since the Voyagers passed by in 1980 and 1981. Unlike Jupiter, whose cloud bands are obvious in visible light, Saturn's cloud features are more subtle in visible wavelengths. The cloud features pop to life when viewed at longer, thermal wavelengths, as in this Cassini VIMS mosaic:

Saturn's north polar hexagon

NASA / JPL / U. Arizona

Saturn's north polar hexagon
This image of Saturn's north pole was taken by Cassini's VIMS spectrometer at a mid-infrared wavelength of 5 microns. It was winter at Saturn's north pole; all illumination is thermal radiation (heat) welling up from Saturn's depths. Some of the heat radiation is blocked by clouds floating in Saturn's atmosphere at about 75 kilometers below the cloud tops that can be seen in visible wavelengths. The pressure at that level is about three times Earth's atmospheric pressure. The patterns in the image are created by alternating cloudy and clear areas. The image has been contrast-reversed so that the glouds show up as bright spots, while open areas appear dark.
There's an even cooler VIMS view of the hexagon, an animation:
Saturn's north polar hexagon

NASA / JPL / U. Arizona

Saturn's north polar hexagon
This movie of Saturn's north pole was taken by Cassini's VIMS spectrometer at a mid-infrared wavelength of 5 microns. It was winter at Saturn's north pole; all illumination is thermal radiation (heat) welling up from Saturn's depths. Some of the heat radiation is blocked by clouds floating in Saturn's atmosphere at about 75 kilometers below the cloud tops that can be seen in visible wavelengths. The pressure at that level is about three times Earth's atmospheric pressure. The patterns in the image are created by alternating cloudy and clear areas. The images have been contrast-reversed so that the clouds show up as bright spots, while open areas appear dark. The 37 frames in the animation (only 13 of which are shown in the thumbnail version) were taken over a period of about an hour, as Saturn rotated about 30 degrees.
The hexagon was first observed in Voyager images of Saturn, and immediately excited curiosity among scientists. In the years following Voyager, an oft-cited explanation for the origin of the hexagon was that it was a standing wave in Saturn's atmosphere. In order for it to be persistent, something needs to be driving it; that something was postulated to be a large, solitary storm observed in Voyager images at a latitude just south of the hexagonal feature. There were problems with this explanation, though, the chief one being that Cassini sees no such solitary storm, yet the hexagon is still there.

In an article published in the April issue of Icarus, Ana Aguiar and her coauthors advance an alternative explanation, and test it in the laboratory. The explanation has to do with the speeds of winds in Saturn's atmosphere. It begins with the following plot, showing how Saturn's wind speeds change with latitude.

Wind speeds on Saturn

NASA / JPL / University of Oxford

Wind speeds on Saturn
Wind speeds on Saturn were derived by tracking the motions of clouds observed by Voyager and Cassini. The fastest winds blow around Saturn's equator; at higher latitudes there are alternating eastward and westward jets. Exactly how fast the winds are blowing depends upon your choice of Saturn's rotation rate, which is generally measured from the rotation rate of its magnetic field. That rotation rate was measured to be slower by Cassini than by Voyager. If you use the Voyager reference rotation rate, most of Saturn's winds are prograde (the air moves eastward relative to Saturn's rotation), shown as the dashed line on this graph. If you use the Cassini reference rotation rate, shown as the solid line, the winds alternate eastward and westward, as they do on Jupiter.
The hexagon corresponds to the latitude of the sharp, pointy, prograde peak at the very top of the above graph, about 78 degrees north. (There's another distinctively shaped band on Saturn, called the Ribbon Wave, that corresponds to the pointy peak at a latitude of about 48 degrees north). That pointy peak is actually one of the smaller ones on the plot, so you might not consider wind speed to be an important factor in driving a unique cloud feature.

Aguiar and her coauthors argue that it's not the wind speeds that are important per se; it's the gradient in wind speeds. Where there are steep contrasts in wind speeds -- adjacent parts of Saturn's atmosphere moving at very different speeds -- you can induce unstable behavior in a fluid, including waves, eddies, and swirls. That little prograde peak in wind speeds at around 78 degrees north is actually the narrowest peak on the graph, so that part of Saturn's atmosphere contains one of the steepest wind speed gradients to be found on the whole planet -- a good place to generate weird atmospheric features, including wavelike disturbances.

In the paper, Aguiar et al. run through a mathematical model that shows how the steep gradient in wind speed can set up a wavelike motion of this high-latitude jet, and that there are likely to be exactly six waves encircling the planet, setting up the hexagon (something that I explain in more detail here), and that wave propagates at about exactly the same speed as the jet flows (meaning that the hexagon will appear nearly stationary with respect to Saturn's rotation). Moreover, they show that the observed wind conditions near the south pole are sufficiently different from those near the north pole that the south pole is not predicted to produce a similar wave, which is good, because there's no hexagon at Saturn's south pole.

Having shown that the idea of wind speed gradients driving the formation of the hexagonal wave, they moved to the laboratory. Fun ensued, and science too.

They set up a cylindrical, rotatable tank 10 centimeters deep and 60 centimeters wide. The tank had a lid and base that were split into concentric sections. They could rotate the inner circle of the lid and floor of the tank at a different rate than they rotated the outer circle of the tank and floor, setting up a gradient in the flow speed of the liquid at the joint between the inner and outer circles. Depending on the relative speeds of the two disks, different things happened. At low relative speeds, there was nothing particularly unusual in the flow, just rotation of the water in the tank. But as the gradient between the two rotating sections was increased, wavelike instabilities started forming at the boundary between the two disks. Depending on conditions, the waves evolved chaotically or sometimes quite stably; there might be as few as two or as many as eight waves encircling the axis of rotation. But for a reasonably wide range of experimental parameters, they produced a wavenumber of 6: a hexagon.

Creating Saturn's hexagon in the laboratory

Courtesy of Ana Aguiar

Creating Saturn's hexagon in the laboratory
This is a top-down view of a laboratory tank in an experiment designed to reproduce the wind conditions near Saturn's north pole. The whole cylindrical tank is 60 centimeters wide. Its lid and base are split into two concentric sections, with the inner circle being 30 centimeters in diameter. The inner and outer circles are rotated at different rates, which sets up an instability at their boundary, producing a standing wave; the number of waves it takes to encircle the "pole" depends on various experimental parameters, including the rotation speed. In this particular case, the wavenumber is 6, producing a hexagon. Dye has been injected into the tank to make the form of the turbulent flow visible. Eddies are produced outside the wave.
Think that image is cool? I've got something even cooler: video. They documented the flow patterns in two ways. To get pretty photos that are analagous to spacecraft photos of Saturn, they injected fluorescent dye into the water in the tank:

To track the precise speed at different points within the fluid, they changed the fluid to a mixture of water and glycerol and seeded it with pellets of Pliolite (the glycerol was used so that the tracer particles would have neutral buoyancy within the fluid):

I should note here something that Aguiar wanted me to mention, which is that her work is not at all the first time that such patterns have been created in the laboratory; here, for instance, is another example. She and her coauthors were just first to publish a paper making a case for so explicit a connection between such laboratory experiments and conditions on Saturn.

They did manage to make a hexagon like the one that's seen on Saturn, but with slightly different choices of initial conditions (spin rates) they generated waves with other wavenumbers too, meaning they got polygons of different shapes. I want to thank Ana Aguiar very much for taking the time to dig these other cases out of her files for me, and especially for being willing to share data that doesn't look like the hexagon-near-Saturn's-pole situation she was trying to reproduce with her experiment. I asked to see them because we may see a hexagon near Saturn's pole, but different conditions around different planetary atmospheres could conceivably produce other shapes. And also because it's just so cool to see something as apparently chaotic and unpredictable as the turbulent flow of a liquid produce geometrical shapes like triangles, septagons, and ovals.

Want wavenumber = 7? Here's a septagon.

Creating Saturn's...septagon(?) in the laboratory

Courtesy of Ana Aguiar

Creating Saturn's...septagon(?) in the laboratory
This is a top-down view of a laboratory tank in an experiment designed to reproduce the wind conditions near Saturn's north pole. The whole cylindrical tank is 60 centimeters wide. Its lid and base are split into two concentric sections, with the inner circle being 30 centimeters in diameter. The inner and outer circles are rotated at different rates, which sets up an instability at their boundary, producing a standing wave; the number of waves it takes to encircle the "pole" depends on various experimental parameters, including the rotation speed. In this particular case, the wavenumber is 7, producing a septagon -- one more "wave" than the number that surrounds Saturn's pole. Dye has been injected into the tank to make the form of the turbulent flow visible. Eddies are produced outside the wave.
How about "Saturn's triangle?" It doesn't exist, but if it ever does, we can explain that.
Three eddies surrounding a pole

Courtesy of Ana Aguiar

Three eddies surrounding a pole
In an experiment designed to simulate the conditions near Saturn's north pole, one experimental setup generated not a hexagon but a triangle.
How about wavenumber = 2? Here's an oval for you.
Two eddies and a pole

Courtesy of Ana Aguiar

Two eddies and a pole
With an experimental setup intended to produce Saturn's north polar hexagon, one choice of initial conditions produced two waves circling the pole, creating an oval shape bounded by two eddies. (Corrupt tape in the experiment's recording device caused the funky checkerboards in this image.)
Just to mess with you, here's the south pole of a planet that does have a polar oval, courtesy of ESA's Venus Express. I'm not saying it's caused by the same phenomenon Aguiar and her coauthors were exploring in the lab; I'm just saying you can get all kinds of polygonal shapes showing up near the poles of planets with deep atmospheres.
Venus' south pole

ESA / VIRTIS / INAF-IASF / Obs. de Paris-LESIA

Venus' south pole
A view of Venus in the thermal infrared, at a wavelength of 5 microns. The brightest part of the image is the uppermost atmosphere reflecting solar radiation on the dayside of Venus. On the nightside, subtle cloud features are visible, especially near the south pole, as thermal radiation is emitted from Venus' upper atmosphere at an altitude of around 60 kilometers (36 miles). This image was captured on April 12, 2006 from a distance of 210,000 kilometers.
Finally, and just for fun: a video of a transition between a wavenumber=4 case and a wavenumber=3 case from Aguiar's lab. Can you imagine how fun it was to have this as a doctoral thesis project? I am sure that the experiments had their moments of tedium and frustration. But just imagine setting up an experiment, an apparently chaotic setup with fluid rotating in a tank, and see these bits of order emerge from that chaos. So cool!

Many, many thanks to Ana Aguar for the numerous emails she exchanged with me as I wrote this post.

 

Or read more blog entries about:

Comments:

David Gash: 12/13/2012 06:50 CST

cool stuff, and very informative too

Greg Mee: 12/31/2012 12:35 CST

Very cool. I had been wondering about that for awhile.

Andrew Planet: 02/01/2013 06:13 CST

Emily's article was a really good read. My knowledge on all of this is pretty basic and as I began reading it I started doubting that it was the winds. How can it be the winds if it is only happening at one of the poles, I thought? Magnetism acting as analogy of a chromatograph of materials relative to gravity, I theorised and whether it would flip sides if the pole changed as on Earth. Doubting myself because I aware of my lack of knowledge, I eagerly read on to find out. I was amazed to find that we have been to duplicate the hexagon in experiments on Earth and create other shapes that might mimic patterns found on other worlds. Emily was very clever to point out describing the situation at Venus that,'' I'm not saying it's caused by the same phenomenon, I'm just saying you can get all kinds of polygonal shapes showing up near the poles of planets with deep atmospheres.'' That's complete objectivity by Emily. The only doubt I had of the cylindrical, rotatable tank experiment is that it had the extra element of being affected by the Earth's gravity on two different speeds, not on the one single flow. I had to ask myself if the atmosphere of Saturn is homogeneous in composition relative to the latter sentence. Saturn is alone by itself gravitationally suspended in outer space in line with the Sun you see, not resting on a larger body gravitationally attracting it as with Earth and the tank. Could we have achieved the same hexagonal shape but with other forces or materials? Like I said I don't know much, so regardless of my doubts I'd rather listen to those that do and what you offer as factual evidence. I'm built that way so I can truly learn and I suppose generally its normal for the mind to question. Thanks again for offering for me to read that. I really enjoyed the article, much more that I would have done watching the documentary I was going to view.

Andrew Planet: 02/01/2013 07:07 CST

I forgot to mention that my previous comment is a copy of what I wrote on the Planetary Society Google + page on the 30th Nov 2012 https://plus.google.com/u/0/111419948721791453320/posts/ZfA12xafmFc

gunter: 02/20/2013 01:29 CST

just an observation: a hexagon has sides equal to the radius, so it would look that there is some kind of a wave lengths involved. similarity in the lagrangian points preceding and trailing orbiting bodies. eigenschwingung in the rotating atmosphere. of the planet 10 times further from the sun then us.

Stefan_K: 05/01/2013 08:59 CDT

Thanks a lot for this stunning article.

hank: 06/20/2013 02:55 CDT

the video after "injected fluorescent dye" is missing

Daniel Cazard: 11/22/2013 05:57 CST

This is one of these things that just makes me sit there and gape like an idiot :) Whenever I'm asked to list my favourite features of our backyard [doesn't happen often], this one is top of the list. I did have to read through this article twice, I confess. Anything about the how come of the hexagon is something I have to read twice. The things that exist... And given that it's so near by, it makes one wonder how bizarre it'll become the farther we go... I have a personal affection for this storm, simply because it exist.

Leave a Comment:

You must be logged in to submit a comment. Log in now.
Facebook Twitter Email RSS AddThis

Blog Search

JOIN THE
PLANETARY SOCIETY

Our Curiosity Knows No Bounds!

Become a member of The Planetary Society and together we will create the future of space exploration.

Join Us

Featured Images

Zodiacal light at the Moon from LADEE

Spitzer Space Telescope
Philae CIVA portrait of Rosetta's solar panels, April 14, 2014
Kepler-186f: A Second Earth
More Images

Fly to an Asteroid!

Travel to Bennu on the OSIRIS-REx spacecraft!

Send your name

Join the New Millennium Committee

Let’s invent the future together!

Become a Member

Connect With Us

Facebook! Twitter! Google+ and more…
Continue the conversation with our online community!