Help Shape the Future of Space Exploration

Join The Planetary Society Now  arrow.png

Join our eNewsletter for updates & action alerts

    Please leave this field empty

Headshot of Emily Lakdawalla

Ices, Oceans, and Fire: Tuesday morning: Goo-ology

Posted by Emily Lakdawalla

16-08-2007 18:51 CDT


The penultimate talk, given by Jeff Kargel, was titled "Theory of Geochemical/Geological Homology Applied to Hydrocarbon and Organic Substances on Icy Satellites and Other Solid Planetary Objects," which needs some translation; I'd call it "Does comparative planetology work at all, especially for Titan?" This talk was so useful that I asked Jeff for a copy of his Powerpoint and am reproducing his text almost entirely here, with some expansion for explanatory purposes. Thank you, Jeff!

He opened with a slide stating a provocative claim: "Mars is Mars-like, NOT Earth-like." (The statement was made by Nick Hoffman, he of "White Mars" fame.) Jeff commented that he could not but agree with the first half of the comment, but thought the second half worth exploring. Mars is, indeed, very different to Earth in a number of important ways:

  • Its gravity is 40% of Earth's.
  • Its geothermal flux [heat output] is about 40% of Earth's.
  • Its atmosphere is 1% as dense as Earth's, dominated by carbon dioxide [not nitrogen or oxygen], 80 Kelvin colder than Earth's, has very low relative humidity, etc....
  • It has no plate tectonics, no oceans, little or no granite [and therefore limited reprocessing of its crust, unlike what has happened on Earth], maybe no life [whereas everything we can see on, in, and above Earth has been affected by life], and has a unique geological history.
  • Mars has a unique volatile assemblage and petrology [meaning that it started out with a different initial elemental budget, which is reflected in the present in different rocks and gases].
With all these differences, you can't expect comparable processes and landforms on both planets. Furthermore, even when the same materials are present on both planets, they behave differently under different conditions. If Mars is so un-Earth-like, how Earth-like could Titan or any other icy satellite possibly be? Is there any hope at all for comparative planetology?
Panorama of the channels at the Huygens landing site

Panorama of the channels at the Huygens landing site
Jeff says there is hope for comparative planetology, and here's his reasoning.
  • Solid planetary bodies are made of many substances.
  • The substances exhibit a wide range of physical properties.
  • The conditions on planetary objects vary widely.
  • Planetary objects exert a

    See other posts from August 2007


    Or read more blog entries about:


    Leave a Comment:

    You must be logged in to submit a comment. Log in now.
Facebook Twitter Email RSS AddThis

Blog Search

Essential Advocacy

Our Advocacy Program 
provides each Society member 
a voice in the process.

Funding is critical. The more 
we have, the more effective 
we can be, translating into more 
missions, more science, 
and more exploration.


Featured Images

Ganymede from Voyager 1
LightSail 2 with mini-DVD
LightSail 2 after antenna deployment
LightSail 2 sail deployment test from +X camera
More Images

Featured Video

The Planetary Post - A Visit To JPL

Watch Now

Space in Images

Pretty pictures and
awe-inspiring science.

See More

Join the New Millennium Committee

Let’s invent the future together!

Become a Member

Connect With Us

Facebook, Twitter, YouTube and more…
Continue the conversation with our online community!