Venus as seen from two different spacecraft
Posted by Emily Lakdawalla
25-07-2007 17:08 CDT
Over the last week or so, ESA, NASA, and the Applied Physics Laboratory have released some preliminary images from ESA's Venus Express and NASA/APL's MESSENGER missions, which performed simultaneous observations of Venus on June 5. Venus Express has been doing science operations there for more than a year, while MESSENGER was just passing through on its way to its first flyby of Mercury in January. (This sounds like a long way off, but it's not much more than four months away, and coming up quickly!)
The two sets of observations will eventually be used by both science teams, working together, to enrich our understanding of Venus. In the short term, though, what the two sets of observations really do is to illustrate how much more Venus Express "sees" at Venus than MESSENGER does. It's not at all a fair comparison -- Venus Express' instruments were designed to penetrate Venus' many layers of clouds, while MESSENGER's were designed to stare at rocks with no interference from any pesky atmosphere. It just serves to show how, when engineers build a spacecraft, they really need to already know quite a bit about the properties of their spacecraft's target in order to design instruments that can perform well.
Anyway, getting back to Venus, here's a nifty little movie that APL posted yesterday, illustrating MESSENGER's departure from Venus. I include information in the caption as it appears on the APL website, although I am virtually certain that the distance information is not correct. (Judging by the amount that the apparent size of Venus changes, it seems that MESSENGER must have been roughly 10 times closer to Venus at the start of the sequence than it was at the end.) I'll change it here if and when APL changes it on their site.It's fun to get a sense of motion from the image, and to consider this the view out MESSENGER's rear window, passing by Venus for the last time; it'll never travel so far away from the Sun again, and is now on a path to the first Mercury encounter. However, it's a bit disappointing that there is absolutely no detail of any kind visible in Venus' clouds. It's like a cue ball. Again, this is not meant as any criticism of MESSENGER; its imaging systems don't have the right wavelength filters to see detail at Venus, they're optimized for rock. But with no features visible at all, I just don't quite get the feeling that this is Venus as opposed to any place else, or even a computer animated crescent.
Venus Express saw a lot more during the encounter. There was a bit of finesse involved in doing "simultaneous" observations. Venus Express was not in the right part of its orbit to perform useful observations of MESSENGER's closest approach point at the same time that MESSENGER was observing -- in fact, it was below MESSENGER's horizon. So the Venus Express team split their plans into two observation types. First, they considered the location over which MESSENGER would be passing, then calculated backward to predict where the clouds over that site would have come from, 12 hours earlier, then photographed those clouds. They also observed the actual close approach point some time after MESSENGER passed by. Here's one image from that observation, which does show lots of details in clouds at an elevation about 30 kilometers above the surface:And here's another one, at a longer wavelength, which reveals the temperature differences due to elevation above Venus' surface. It's compared, on the right, to a model of Venus' topography derived from Magellan radar data, and I was really impressed by the close match in the locations of some of the major chasmata crossing Venus near Aphrodite Terra.
Or read more blog entries about: