Help Shape the Future of Space Exploration

Join The Planetary Society Now  arrow.png

Join our eNewsletter for updates & action alerts

    Please leave this field empty

Casey Profile Picture Thumbnail

Continued Victories for Planetary Exploration

For the second year in a row Congress rejects cuts requested by the White House

Posted by Casey Dreier

16-01-2014 19:33 CST

Topics: FY2014 NASA Budget, Explaining Policy, Space Policy, Future Mission Concepts, Plutonium-238

The Society and its members have worked hard over the past year and a half to restore funding for NASA’s Planetary Science Division. This week we savor the fruits of that labor as Congress passed a budget that allocated $127 million more to solar system exploration than requested by the White House. While we’re still below our goal of $1.5 billion – the historical average for the program – this is the second year in a row that Congress rejected the full cuts proposed by the White House, and that is a powerful statement.

The Planetary Society released a statement of support for this spending bill, and formally thanked Congress for once again stepping up on behalf of solar system exploration. Over fifty thousand messages were sent to Congress and the President by members and supporters of The Planetary Society in 2013, and those made a difference.

We will continue our aggressive campaign for planetary exploration this year as we work to ensure a Mars sample return, send out a fleet of small missions to all corners of the solar system, maintain leading scientific capability, and explore the outer solar system. The Society as recently as December called for President Obama to embrace a flagship mission to explore Europa, and we hope that this continued support by Congress and compelling new evidence for water plumes help motivate the Administration to request an increased budget in 2015.

NASA’s total budget for 2014 will be $17.65 billion, a very good number, and about $800 million more than last year’s post-sequester amount. For additional analysis of the rest of NASA’s budget, including SLS/Orion and Commercial Crew, I recommend Jeff Foust’s analysis at SpacePolitics.

The Bill

NASA’s Planetary Science Division will receive $1.345 billion in 2014, compared to the President’s request of $1.217 billion. Unlike last year, there are no additional sequester cuts that will shrink this number. Congress even included a strongly worded statement in the bill’s accompanying report warning NASA not to shift this money away to other projects, something they tried to do in 2013.

Congress directed these budget increases to the Discovery program, which manages small solar system missions; to the continued operation of MESSENGER through 2015; to the Mars Exploration Program so it can get a jump-start on the Mars 2020 rover; and applies an additional $80 million towards early-stage concept design and instrument study for the Europa Clipper mission, even though the White House and NASA have no plans to make this mission a reality. In lieu of a formal mission, NASA will spend the money refining the mission design and instrumentation, activities that could help reduce the total cost should the White House change its mind in the future.

FY2014 Congressional Omnibus Allocations for Planetary Science

Van Kane

FY2014 Congressional Omnibus Allocations for Planetary Science
Congress provided an additional $127 million for Planetary Science beyond what the White House requested in 2014. This chart compares the FY13 Congressional appropriation, the FY14 Presidential request, and the FY14 Congressional appropriation for major programs within Planetary Science.

The budget forbids the Education and Public Outreach reorganization first proposed by the White House, which caused much confusion, worry, and consternation within the scientific and educator community, and requests that more study be done on this issue before Congress assents to it. The bill also fully funds the levels of scientific research requested by White House, and doubles the nation’s budget for near-Earth object detection to $40.5 million (a good thing).

Plutonium-238 Fuel Pellet Department of Energy

The bill also accepts the White House’s proposal to shift monetary responsibility for maintaining the nation’s stockpile of plutonium-238 from the Department of Energy to NASA, which adds a new $50 million/year burden on the Planetary Science Division. I find the plutonium-238 situation particularly galling, since the Department of Energy’s mission is to provide radioactive isotopes for other areas of government, and for the past fifty years has shouldered the (relatively) small cost of maintaining this infrastructure. NASA is not even allowed to use the entire nation’s stockpile of plutonium-238, though NASA is now paying for its maintenance and (separately) for its new production. But, to look at this positively, plutonium-238 shortages no longer seem to threaten solar system exploration. That’s great news, no matter who pays for it.

What’s Next

The book is not closed on 2014. Now that NASA has its money, it has to spend it. It does this through its operating plan, where the agency can make minor adjustments to project funding based on programmatic needs. Last year NASA abused this process and tried to shift all additional money allocated for Planetary Science by Congress to unrelated projects. I feel that this is unlikely to happen again, but it’s something that we will be watching closely. I know it sounds crazy, but sometimes you have to ensure that NASA spends planetary money on planetary projects.

The whole cycle begins again with the release of the President’s 2015 budget request, which looks to be sometime in early March. It has been delayed slightly in order to incorporate feedback from the bill Congress just passed today, so there is some hope that the budgetary situation for Planetary Science will improve next year.

The Europa Clipper spacecraft concept

NASA / JPL-Caltech / Michael Carroll

The Europa Clipper spacecraft concept
The Clipper spacecraft flies over the surface of Europa in this artist's rendering. NASA is currently studying this reduced-cost mission which would use at least 48 flybys to explore the moon instead of entering into orbit.

This same budget request we will also  the fate of Cassini. Last year’s budget request projected just enough money to shut down the mission (i.e. prematurely crash it into something). It’s also possible (though highly unlikely) that the White House could heed our call and include a “new start” for the Europa Clipper mission in this budget, something which would likely be embraced by Congress. Adding a Europa mission would require the total budget increase to around $1.5 billion, which is not coincidentally the number we’ve been arguing for since 2012.

Final Thoughts

If you took the time to write or call Congress to ask for increased planetary science funding 2013, pat yourself on the back: this is a victory for you and all fans of solar system exploration. Thank you for stepping up and creating an unprecedented amount of public support for this unique program.

Congress deserves thanks for this, too, which is something said all too rarely. They listened to the strong public and scientific support for planetary exploration and worked to make things better. We are fortunate to have the strong proponents in the House and Senate that we do, and particular thanks are due to Rep. Adam Schiff, Rep. John Culberson, Sen. Dianne Feinstein, Rep. Lamar Smith (for the great planetary language in the 2013 NASA Authorization bill), Sen. Barbara Mikulski, and Rep. Frank Wolf. You’ll notice that this is a bipartisan list of legislators, another situation which is all too rare these days.

Despite this good news, we’ve heard rumblings that the President’s budget request in 2015 is not good. Those are just rumors. But remember that even it it comes to pass, we can change the outcome. We’ve seen that public pressure is effective; the extra $127 million for planetary is here because we stood together and fought for a future of exploration. We may have to do so again.

See other posts from January 2014


Or read more blog entries about: FY2014 NASA Budget, Explaining Policy, Space Policy, Future Mission Concepts, Plutonium-238


Doug Currie: 01/17/2014 12:29 CST

Hi Casey, thank you for the report for the new budgets especially the 2014 budget and I am glad you have some good news to report for planetary sciences. Sincerely Doug

Gregory Katz: 01/17/2014 11:47 CST

I'm glad for the good news. I'm sure the Planetary Society did great work in making it happen. I wrote in myself. Two questions though: Were there any particular legislators that were the most important in making it happen? I'd like to know who to support. Also, it bugs me a little bit that the goal is less than the historical average. Shouldn't we be shooting for above the historical average? Or is that just too unrealistic?

Casey Dreier: 01/17/2014 01:17 CST

Gregory: I list some key legislators at the end of the "Final Thoughts" section, both they and their staffs have been very helpful. I'm disappointed it's not at the historical average, too, but this is a multi-year effort, and every step towards our goal helps. I hesitate to say anything is "unrealistic" since we don't want to put up artificial limits for ourselves, but I do think that $1.5B would preserve a good balance within the space sciences directorate within NASA.

Swapnil Saxena: 01/17/2014 01:25 CST

I'm an Indian and I have to say I'm really glad to hear the good news. Well done Planetary Society! Looking forward to the Europa mission!!

jigme yonten: 01/24/2014 01:03 CST

I surely did pat myself on my back :),because it is surely a very good good news to hear. I am pretty sure this team will make a difference and site a new discoveries for the world to rejoice someday, I have faith for it. Good luck and god bless you all.

Leave a Comment:

You must be logged in to submit a comment. Log in now.
Facebook Twitter Email RSS AddThis

Blog Search

Planetary Defense

An asteroid or comet headed for Earth is the only large-scale natural disaster we can prevent. Working together to fund our Shoemaker NEO Grants for astronomers, we can help save the world.


Featured Images

LightSail 2 and Prox-1
Bill Nye at LightSail 2 pre-ship review
LightSail 2 pre-ship review team photo
Swirling maelstrom
More Images

Featured Video

Class 9: Saturn, Uranus, and Neptune

Watch Now

Space in Images

Pretty pictures and
awe-inspiring science.

See More

Join The Planetary Society

Let’s explore the cosmos together!

Become a Member

Connect With Us

Facebook, Twitter, YouTube and more…
Continue the conversation with our online community!