Join Donate

Emily LakdawallaOctober 23, 2007

Reporting from the second Mars Science Laboratory landing site selection meeting

I am sitting in an unbelievably packed (and clearly too small) meeting room at the Courtyard Marriott hotel in Pasadena along with what must be over 150 interested members of the Mars community for the second of three Mars Science Laboratory landing site selection meetings. Just as the landing site selection process was for the Mars Exploration Rovers (but not for Phoenix), this process has been thrown wide open to anyone in the community who is interested in helping to determine where Mars Science Laboratory should go. While many of the faces here are familiar to me from the Mars Exploration Rover mission, there are also a bunch of "outsiders," other members of the Mars community who are currently working on orbital missions, and many faces I've never seen before.

Mars Science Laboratory descends


Mars Science Laboratory descends
In this still from a movie of Mars Science Laboratory's landing, the rover descends on cables from the backshell as retrorockets fire to slow its descent.
The conference runs for three days. The first day is devoted largely to explanations of what constraints there are on landing the rover. MSL (I generally hate abbreviations, but as this mission has already been through two different versions of the name with the same abbreviation, so I guess I'll stick with it) has more precision capability in its landing than previous missions; its landing "ellipse" is much more circular than previous missions, about 25 kilometers long by 20 kilometers wide, and at that it covers a much smaller area than the landing ellipses for Spirit and Opportunity, which were about 90 kilometers long by about 10 kilometers wide. That smaller and more circular ellipse, along with a landing system that will set the rover down on its wheels rather than bounce it around within airbags, opens up what the engineers like to call the "parameter space" -- it will allow MSL to get within tighter spots (like inside canyons or craters) and land on rougher or more sloping terrain than was available to Spirit and Opportunity.

That won't make landing site selection any easier, especially since there is MUCH more data available to scientists now. From space, Mars Global Surveyor, Mars Odyssey, Mars Express, and especially Mars Reconnaissance Orbiter have provided high-resolution views of not only the geomorphology but also the chemistry of many, many exciting-looking spots on Mars. (I'll have more to say about the recent release of Mars Reconnaissance Orbiter CRISM data to support the site selection process later.)

Another challenge is that because the rover and its entry, descent, and landing system isn't built yet, the engineering constraints keep changing. This morning they have already announced two big problems that have led to recent changes in site constraints. First, they were trying to develop new actuators that employ a dry rather than a wet lubricant, which would permit the rover to be operated at lower temperatures than Spirit and Opportunity can tolerate. That development effort has ended in failure, so now they have temperature constraints, which I assume lead most directly to a more restricted range in altitude and latitude. (Note that because Mars' winters are longer in the southern hemisphere, you can go to higher northern latitudes than you can to southern latitudes.)

The other problem is that because MSL is big and heavy, they have found the material that they have used in the past for the heat shield, something called SLA-561V, is not going to work for this mission, and they're switching to something else called PICA. Attempting to use the original material was forcing them to go to slower, shallower entries and an unacceptably low-altitude engineering constraint (allowing a longer path through the atmosphere for landing); moving to the new PICA material will make life challenging for the engineers but will return most of the altitude range to the scientists trying to choose landing sites.

I'll be here all day today and again on Thursday, and I'll post notes as quickly as I can. Stay tuned!

To follow along, check out the MSL landing site information website, where they are supposed to be posting nearly all the presentations given at this meeting, and where they have links to all the data being collected by all the orbiting missions.

Read more:

You are here:
Emily Lakdawalla 2017 headshot square serene
Emily Lakdawalla

Solar System Specialist for The Planetary Society
Read more articles by Emily Lakdawalla

Comments & Sharing
Bill Nye and people
Let's Change the World

Become a member of The Planetary Society and together we will create the future of space exploration.

Join Today

The Planetary Fund

Help advance robotic and human space exploration, defend our planet, and search for life.


"We're changing the world. Are you in?"
- CEO Bill Nye

Sign Up for Email Updates