Help Shape the Future of Space Exploration

Join The Planetary Society Now  arrow.png

Join our eNewsletter for updates & action alerts

    Please leave this field empty

Headshot of Emily Lakdawalla

A moon with atmosphere

Posted by Emily Lakdawalla

08-04-2015 13:27 CDT

Topics: Jupiter's moons, Io, Hubble Space Telescope, atmospheres, Callisto, explaining science

What is the solar system moon with the densest atmosphere? Most space fans know that the answer is Titan; with a surface atmospheric pressure of 1.4 bars, its air is thicker than Earth's. A few of you might know that Triton's is the next densest. But what's the third? Fourth? Do any other moons even have atmospheres? In fact, they do; and one such atmosphere has just been discovered.

No other moon's atmosphere is quite like Titan's smoggy sky. From space, we can see straight to the other moons' surfaces, with no clouds or haze in the way. Most moons' atmospheres are extremely tenuous, so much so that their constituent molecules never collide with each other. Such collisionless atmospheres are called exospheres. The Moon has an exosphere, as does the planet Mercury.

A very few moons have atmospheres that are dense enough for their gas molecules to collide with each other. This can happen even in a pretty thin atmosphere. Triton's had a surface pressure of 14 microbars when Voyager 2 flew by. As the seasons have progressed on Triton the atmospheric pressure has increased by a factor of three or four, but it's still 20,000 times less dense than Earth's. Still, when air molecules can collide, you can have wind, and even weather. Such an atmosphere can also offer a moon's surface some protection from the particles flung around in giant planet magnetospheres. You can see on Triton how upper-level winds blow the tops of its geysers away. If we're very lucky, we'll see similar features when New Horizons passes Pluto this summer. (Pluto's atmosphere is denser than Triton's.)

Triton color global view

NASA / JPL / Ted Stryk

Triton color global view
Voyager 2 acquired the images for this high-resolution mosaic of Triton on August 25, 1989. The south pole is at the left; several of Triton's famous south polar geysers are visible. Toward the equator at right, Triton is covered with a strange "cantaloupe terrain".

So which moons other than Titan and Triton have weather? We think there are two. The third-densest atmosphere in the solar system is Io's. From observations with the Submillimeter Array, Arielle Moullet and three coauthors measured sulfur dioxide, sulfur monoxide, and sodium chloride in its air. (Yes, salt is a constituent of Io's atmosphere!) Some of these gases, probably including all of the salt, is fed directly to Io's atmosphere by its constantly erupting volcanoes, but there's too much sulfur dioxide for all of it to be volcanic; some of it has to come from sublimating sulfur dioxide frost.

Animation of Tvashtar and Pele's Plumes

NASA / JPL / SSI / Gordan Ugarkovic

Animation of Tvashtar and Pele's Plumes
This animation, composed of UV3 frames from the Cassini Imaging Science Subsystem (ISS) taken on January 2, 2001 and magnified by a factor of 2, shows plumes from Io's Tvashtar and Pele Paterae (volcanoes).

At the surface, the peak pressure is around 1.9 nanobars -- that is to say, Earth's atmosphere is 200 million times denser than Io's. But it's still an atmosphere, and a variable one. Io's surface breathes over the course of its day, exhaling sulfur dioxide as it warms in sunlight, and pulling it back down to the surface as it cools at night. The volcanoes heat their local areas, making patches of denser atmosphere and out-flowing winds.

One of the weirdest things in Io's atmosphere is a consequence of it having no magnetic field while being embedded inside Jupiter's. Jupiter's magnetic field sweeps across Io's atmosphere once each Jupiter day, slamming into the back of Io's atmosphere. The magnetic field moves the ions in Io's atmosphere, but not the neutral molecules, so the moving ions crash into the neutral molecules, moving as a current through Io's resistant neutral atmosphere. The interaction of Jupiter's magnetic field with Io's ionosphere has a visible manifestation as a glowing Io footprint within Jupiter's aurora. (For further reading, I recommend this PDF of a PowerPoint presentation on Io's atmosphere that had no name on it -- please speak up in the comments if you know whose presentation it is!)

Satellite footprints in Jupiter's northern aurora

NASA/ESA, John Clarke (University of Michigan)

Satellite footprints in Jupiter's northern aurora
Auroras are curtains of light resulting from high-energy electrons racing along the planet's magnetic field into the upper atmosphere. The electrons excite atmospheric gases, causing them to glow. The image shows the main oval of the aurora, which is centered on the magnetic north pole, plus more diffuse emissions inside the polar cap. Though the aurora resembles the same phenomenon that crowns Earth's polar regions, the Hubble image shows unique emissions from the magnetic "footprints" of three of Jupiter's largest moons. (These points are reached by following Jupiter's magnetic field from each satellite down to the planet). Auroral footprints can be seen in this image from Io (along the left hand limb), Ganymede (near the center), and Europa (just below and to the right of Ganymede's auroral footprint). These emissions, produced by electric currents generated by the satellites, flow along Jupiter's magnetic field, bouncing in and out of the upper atmosphere. They are unlike anything seen on Earth.

Okay, so how about the fourth densest atmosphere? A new paper in press at Icarus by Nathanial Cunningham and five coauthors suggests that there is one more known collisional atmosphere among the solar system's moons. The fourth densest moon atmosphere in the solar system is (drum roll please):



Callisto in color from Galileo orbit E11

NASA / JPL / Ted Stryk

Callisto in color from Galileo orbit E11
Galileo captured this global view of Callisto on its 11th orbit of Jupiter, on November 5, 1997.

Cunningham and coauthors used the Cosmic Origins Spectrograph on Hubble to detect the telltale ultraviolet emission of atomic oxygen and determine its abundance. Oxygen probably forms at Callisto when water ice molecules at the surface are split into hydrogen and oxygen atoms; some of the lightweight hydrogen escapes from the atmosphere entirely, leaving the heavier oxygen behind. John Spencer (who was second author on the paper) helped me convert from atmospheric column abundances to surface pressures. Cunningham and coauthors' work suggests that Callisto's leading hemisphere has a surface atmospheric pressure of 26 picobars -- that is, it is 40 billion times less dense than Earth's -- but that the air over its trailing hemisphere may be 10 times denser.

A dynamic atmosphere, even though very thin, slightly shifts our view of Callisto. Callisto is the outermost of the Galilean satellites and also, to use a highly technical term, the deadest. Its gravity field suggests that, unlike the other Galilean moons, it never got warm enough to differentiate into a rocky core and icy mantle, remaining instead a primitive mixture of ice and rock all the way down. A couple of years ago, Jeff Moore postulated that Titan might not have internal geological activity and may just be "Callisto with weather." It turns out that Callisto may have weather! Callisto's atmosphere is more than dense enough for its molecules to collide with each other.

Oxygen atmospheres form at Europa and Ganymede for the same reason that they form at Callisto. But their oxygen atmospheres are a factor of a few less dense than Callisto's, making theirs exospheres, not collisional atmospheres. No wind, and no weather. (At least not at present.)

So here you go: the unlikely set of four solar system moons known to have atmospheres dense enough for weather. In order: Saturn's moon Titan; Neptune's moon Triton; and Jupiter's moons Io and Callisto.

Moons with atmospheres

NASA / JPL / SSI / Ted Stryk / Jason Perry / Emily Lakdawalla

Moons with atmospheres
There are four moons in the solar system that are known to have collisional atmospheres. In order of decreasing atmospheric column density, they are: Saturn's Titan, Neptune's Triton, and Jupiter's Io and Callisto.

One final remark. I think that the discovery of a collisonal atmosphere at Callisto is an incredibly cool result, the kind of thing you'd see on all the space blogs. The reason that you don't see it on other blogs is because it hasn't been the subject of a press release, and press releases drive most news reporting. If you read other space sites today, you'll probably read about how the moon formed or an observation of organic molecules in an infant stellar system, two cool results that were the subjects of press releases today. You may even read about the discovery (again) of subsurface ice on Mars. But there are lots of other things being discovered out there. You can find out about them by reading the tables of contents of the main planetary science journals, like Icarus, the Journal of Geophysical Research - Planets, Planetary and Space Science, and others. That's how I found out about Callisto's atmosphere!

See other posts from April 2015


Or read more blog entries about: Jupiter's moons, Io, Hubble Space Telescope, atmospheres, Callisto, explaining science


Inkerman: 04/08/2015 03:29 CDT

Emily, superb post as ever. Joined the P Soc a few months ago as a result of your blog. Seemed unfair to enjoy it for free!

Brian Schmidt: 04/08/2015 07:34 CDT

I believe part of New Horizons' mission is to investigate potential atmospheric transfer from Pluto to Charon, so we may soon find Charon taking up to third place in this list.

Guillermo Abramson: 04/08/2015 07:55 CDT

Cool indeed. And that´s why I keep reading you year after year.

Jonathan Ursin: 04/08/2015 08:23 CDT

My guesses were Io and Enceladus. I wonder when you will be writing an article comparing atmospheres in other solar systems?

Steven Taylor: 04/09/2015 03:47 CDT

I seem to remember reading years ago that the atmosphere on Titan is 4 times denser than the Earth`s, whilst having the quoted 1.4 bar pressure. Does anyone know if this is the correct figure? Thank you.

Karen: 04/09/2015 05:30 CDT

Do you have any data on what the flux of high energy ions is at different points in the Jupiter-Io system? I've always wondered whether it might be possible to use Jupiter as a natural particle accelerator for "free" antimatter production - but that takes energies in the GeV range. If there was somewhere that there was a natural high flux of high energy particles one could set up magnetic focusing / further acceleration toward a collision target and trap.

aspaceman: 04/09/2015 09:03 CDT

on the third page of the io's atmosphere presentation there is a figure with reference to a banana. can anyone clear up why that is for me? satellite footprints are a totally new concept to me. that is so beautiful, thank you. and to Brian's comment, atmosphere exchange at pluto/charon would be a marvellous phenomenon to study. so many new concepts, thank you everyone.

David Frankis: 04/09/2015 05:07 CDT

Steven, yes, it's just the ideal gas law. Titan's atmosphere has pretty much the same molecular weight as Earth's, but only about a third the temperature (100K as opposed to 300K), so for a given pressure it's about three times as dense. A pressure of 1.4 times Earth thus leads to a density about 4 times Earth's.

Steven Taylor: 04/10/2015 02:17 CDT

David, Thanks for responding with a detailed explanation. (It`s well over 40 years since I attended school here in London).

David Frankis: 04/12/2015 01:58 CDT

Steven, you're welcome! It's nice to know that not all comments are drive-bys.

Leave a Comment:

You must be logged in to submit a comment. Log in now.
Facebook Twitter Email RSS AddThis

Blog Search

Planetary Defense

An asteroid or comet headed for Earth is the only large-scale natural disaster we can prevent. Working together to fund our Shoemaker NEO Grants for astronomers, we can help save the world.


Featured Images

Jupiter in approximate true color during Juno perijove 4
Bill Nye at LightSail 2 pre-ship review
LightSail 2 and Prox-1
LightSail 2 pre-ship review team photo
More Images

Featured Video

Class 9: Saturn, Uranus, and Neptune

Watch Now

Space in Images

Pretty pictures and
awe-inspiring science.

See More

Join The Planetary Society

Let’s explore the cosmos together!

Become a Member

Connect With Us

Facebook, Twitter, YouTube and more…
Continue the conversation with our online community!