WHAT WE DO

JOINRENEWJOIN

 

The Planetary Society Blog

By Emily Lakdawalla




How does Lutetia compare to the other asteroids and comets visited by spacecraft?

Jul. 15, 2010 | 14:33 PDT | 21:33 UTC
We need your help.
Please donate to support our blog, website, and podcast.
RSS 2.0 News Feed

Almost a week after Rosetta flew past Lutetia, the asteroid is now a distant pinprick of light to the spacecraft, and the science team is getting down to the business of analyzing their data. To help them place things in context, I've prepared a new version of my "asteroids and comets to scale" image, laid out to be easy to drop into your slide presentation software of choice:

All asteroids and comets visited by spacecraft as of June 2010
All asteroids and comets visited by spacecraft as of June 2010
The total of four comets and nine asteroid systems (including ten separate bodies) that have been examined up close by spacecraft are shown here to scale with each other (100 meters per pixel, in the fully enlarged version). Most of these were visited only briefly, in flyby missions, so we have only one point of view on each; only Eros and Itokawa were orbited and mapped completely.

This image is also available without text, and as a larger version at 20 meters per pixel (8600x6250 pixels, 9.4 MB).

Credits: Montage by Emily Lakdawalla. Ida, Dactyl, Braille, Annefrank, Gaspra, Borrelly: NASA / JPL / Ted Stryk. Steins: ESA / OSIRIS team. Eros: NASA / JHUAPL. Itokawa: ISAS / JAXA / Emily Lakdawalla. Mathilde: NASA / JHUAPL / Ted Stryk. Lutetia: ESA / OSIRIS team / Emily Lakdawalla. Halley:: Russian Academy of Sciences / Ted Stryk. Tempel 1: NASA / JPL / UMD. Wild 2: NASA / JPL.
Lutetia is big relative to the others, isn't it? I had to totally rearrange things to acommodate its enormous bulk; you might enjoy comparing this to my previous version of the montage, produced following the Steins flyby.

A word on the Lutetia image: I wanted to use one of the two highest-resolution views captured near closest approach, but both of those views were truncated at the edges because the spacecraft was so close to the asteroid; the asteroid grew too large to fit within OSIRIS' field of view. I used the next-to-last image in the series released by ESA, taken two minutes prior to closest approach, and borrowed a bit of the image taken about three minutes earlier to fill in the truncated bit. It's not a perfect reconstruction because Lutetia's motion past the asteroid made it appear to rotate between the two images; but it's close enough for this montage. I was aided in this endeavour by Daniel Muller, who was able to calculate range information for me for those four images. With that and OSIRIS' angular resolution of 18.6 microrad per pixel, I figured out the approximate pixel scale of the images (at the center of the visible disk). In case this information will be helpful to anybody else playing around with the photos, here it is:

Four views of Lutetia from Rosetta
Time before closest approach (min:sec)Range (km)Resolution (m/pix)
8:008414156.5
4:405635104.8
2:00377670.2
1:50368866.4


When's the next time the montage will need to be updated? Not very long from now! On November 4, 2010, Deep Impact will fly past 103P/Hartley 2, and we'll have another comet nucleus to add to the lineup. It shouldn't affect the layout much, though, because Hartley 2 will be one of the smaller bodies visited by a spacecraft; its nucleus is estimated to be only a bit over a kilometer across, about the size of Dactyl. Next year, on February 14, Stardust will fly past Tempel 1 again, hopefully giving us a view of the comet nucleus with its new crater, but since Stardust's camera is not as good as Deep Impact's I think it's likely I'll choose not to update the photo.

But next summer, about exactly a year from now, Dawn will arrive at Vesta, the asteroid belt's second-largest resident. And while Vesta is technically an asteroid, it won't make a whole heck of a lot of sense to include it with this montage. To get a sense of how Vesta compares to all the things that we've visited before, here is Vesta and the same montage as above, presented at the same scale of two kilometers per pixel:

Vesta at a scale of 2 km/pixel All asteroids and comets visited by spacecraft as of June 2010 (2 km/pixel)


Of course, Dawn's going to go on to visit Ceres in 2015...here's that one, again at 2 km/pixel...

Ceres at a scale of 2 km/pixel


They're just not in the same class, are they?

Post this page to: del.icio.us Yahoo! MyWeb Digg reddit Furl Blinklist Spurl

Comments

Superb work
Emily, that is a seriously useful graphic. I had read that Lutetia was the largest asteroid yet visited by a spaceprobe and mentioned that in my own report at http://skymania.com/wp/2010/07/rosettas-hot-date-with-lutetia.html. But I had not appreciated how much bigger. You show us in a glance, and it is quite a surprise to see how much it dwarfs Gaspra, for example. Thank you!
#1 - Paul Sutherland - 07/15/2010 - 14:51
Lovely. I may have to get in a new supply of pixels at this rate.

Though I confess my first (rather tired at the end of a long day) thought on reading the title was "Golly! She's analysed those grooves, compared impact histories and surface compositions and worked out whether it's a rubble pile already?"
#2 - Surreyguy - 07/15/2010 - 15:09
Nice!
Thanks Emily. You are the master of new space goodies!
#3 - Tom` - 07/15/2010 - 15:13
To paraphrase Asimov...
The asteroid belt consists of Ceres, Vesta, and debris.
#4 - Tony Fisk - 07/15/2010 - 19:41
To paraphrase Mark Adler...
The solar system consists of four planets and a bunch of little rocks.
#5 - Emily - 07/15/2010 - 22:05
Thx !
Fantastic poster, many thanks!
#6 - Ingo Althofer - 07/16/2010 - 05:08
Why png?
Thanks Emily, so cool! =)

But why save those images as png? That seems a heavy choice. The larger one as a jpeg, 10/12 high quality (almost no visible difference) weighs only little above 3 MB.
#7 - Manu - 07/16/2010 - 13:31
Lutetia 3D
De las imagenes obtuve dos para formar un par estereo
creo que los resultados son buenos
http://estereocosas.webs.com/lutetia.htm
saludos.
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
I got two of the images to form a stereo pair.
I think the results are good
greetings.
#8 - perLuis - 07/16/2010 - 18:55
Albedos?
I'm curious if your montage is also useful for comparing the relative albedos of the visited asteroids.
#9 - Karl Littau - 07/19/2010 - 13:01
Thanks - awesome chart!
Thankyou - that's a wonderful comparison which sure puts these minor planets in perspective!

I'd read that Lutetia was the largest asteroid we've yet visited but I hadn't realised just *how* much larger than the others it was nor how tiny Itokawa is.

Thanks again, much appreciated.

- Messier Tidy Upper aka. StevoR
#10 - Messier Tidy Upper (StevoR) - 07/20/2010 - 07:00
Nice work
Very nice work. It's really easy to lose your sense of scale when looking through a spacecraft camera, because everything is usually normalized. This helps a lot.
#11 - Phil K - 07/20/2010 - 08:42
Great as a poster
I just printed out the high-res. version as a poster and it looks great. Stops people in the hallway, and we are used to fancy astro-images.
#12 - Martin E. - 07/20/2010 - 10:59
Replies to comments
@Manu: Why PNG? Because the difference is visible, especially near the high-contrast edges. I use JPEG for most images but when it is something that I will want to refer to or edit in the future, I keep it as PNG.

@Karl: No, there was no attempt to compare albedos; the original images are not calibrated properly for doing that. They're all stretched. And I think there's quite a lot of albedo variation among these bodies.

@Martin: cool!
#13 - Emily - 07/20/2010 - 15:40
The Injustice Of It All
While striking, a montage like this - once picked up by the media - will have SO MANY people shaking their heads and saying "THEY ALL LOOK ALIKE! Why are we wasting so many billions on space exploration when THEY ALL LOOK ALIKE?"

[Sigh]. You know this is going to happen. Just wait a few more days until it hits Fox News.
#14 - Paul Buckley - 07/20/2010 - 16:45
WOW amazing work!
Welldone, congrats and many thanks!
Where i can find database of all registered asteroids? Thanks by aftermath!
#15 - Maxim - 07/20/2010 - 17:31
Sweet
This is terrific. It really puts it into perspective. But I think you've missed one: 132524 APL, which was visited by New Horizons in '06.
#16 - Grimbold - 07/20/2010 - 17:53
Wow!
Great job, Emily and Ted, as always!

It's so cool to see all of these images together in a single figure.
#17 - Hal Weaver - 07/26/2010 - 11:17
Very cool!
Awesome montage!
#18 - Carolyn - 07/27/2010 - 06:12
great image indeed!!
I was really impressed by this composite and the superb quality, in particular about the one from comet Halley in 1986 taken by the Vega 2 spacecraft. I have never seen that one, where did you get it from?
#19 - gerhard hahn - 07/28/2010 - 06:14
Thanks, Hal :)

Gerhard: It was produced by Ted Stryk, who is one of the amazing amateurs who work on archived mission data, employing modern computing power and Photoshop techniques to old data. Do a Google search on "site:planetary.org stryk" and you'll see I feature his work often. Here's where I originally posted that one. http://www.planetary.org/blog/article/00001611/ He doesn't post all his stuff to any particular website, but some of it is at planetimages.blogspot.com.
#20 - Emily - 07/28/2010 - 21:09
More pics available
I read more than 400 pics were taken of this celestial body. And in a cofrerence, the lecturer talked about lutetia against the saturn rings and the auditorium broke out in tears. Is it possible to have access to the rest of the material?

Thank you.
#21 - Frutty - 08/31/2010 - 18:08
wonderful -- we use it all the time
There is probably a fractal theory for how you can fill up all paper with all of the asteroids :-) Poor Itokawa will soon be a speck.
Cheers,
Erik and the asteroid people at UCSC
#22 - Erik Asphaug - 08/29/2011 - 02:32
Thanks
Eric, I'm very glad to be of help -- that's why I made the montage in the first place. I plan to update it next when we get a suitably high-res image of Vesta, or when the Rosetta team sends the Lutetia data to the PDS, whichever comes first. As soon as that Lutetia data hits I'll make a color version!
#23 - Emily - 08/29/2011 - 07:16
Name
E-mail (Will not appear online)
Title
Comment
To prevent automated Bots form spamming, please enter the text you see in the image below in the appropriate input box. Your comment will only be submitted if the strings match. Please ensure that your browser supports and accepts cookies, or your comment cannot be verified correctly.



This comment form is powered by GentleSource Comment Script. It can be included in PHP or HTML files and allows visitors to leave comments on the website.



Emily's on Twitter! »

Sign up for email updates!
Email address:
(optional) Your name: